Key Highlights

● Utilities were the best-performing S&P 500 sector for the week.

● Consumer staples and energy tied for second place.

● Utilities rose despite the 10-year Treasury yield near a 24-year high.

● Vistra rose after a conditional Department of Energy loan commitment.

Utilities were the best-performing S&P 500 sector over the week ended Friday, October 9, according to market data. The Utilities Select Sector SPDR fund posted a strong weekly gain, just ahead of consumer staples and energy, which tied for second place, with health care close behind. At the other end of the table, technology and industrials finished the week slightly lower.

That ranking says a lot about investors' mood. Utilities, staples and health care are classic defensive sectors: their sales depend less on the economic cycle because people keep paying power bills, buying groceries and filling prescriptions in good times and bad. Consumer staples posted their second-best week since 2022.

Why defensives are in demand

Several worries pushed investors toward safety. On Thursday, a report that OpenAI's annualized revenue was about $50 billion, roughly $20 billion below a figure that had circulated weeks earlier, rattled the AI trade. The PHLX Semiconductor Index fell sharply over the week, and one market newsletter said leadership had moved out of the AI trade.

The economy is also sending mixed signals. September payrolls rose by just 29,000, and Friday's University of Michigan survey showed consumer sentiment at 46.3, its lowest since May. Fund-flow data showed a record $19.78 billion flowing into US bond funds in the latest week, while US equity funds lost $5.11 billion.

The puzzle of high yields

The utilities rally is notable because the sector is usually sensitive to interest rates. Utilities borrow heavily to build power plants and grids, and their steady dividends compete with bond yields for income-seeking investors. With the 10-year Treasury yield near a 24-year high and the Fed having raised rates in September for the first time since 2023, the backdrop would normally be a headwind.

Part of the answer may be that yields eased slightly over the week after peaking on Wednesday. Another factor is the AI power story: some utilities and independent power producers are seen as beneficiaries of rising electricity demand from data centres.

Friday's movers

On Friday itself, utilities were steady rather than spectacular. PG&E (NYSE:PCG) rose $0.46 to $13.13 in a quiet session for company-specific news, with investors looking ahead to its third-quarter call on October 22. Edison International (NYSE:EIX) climbed to $55.30, while Duke Energy (NYSE:DUK) edged down to $116.65.

Vistra (NYSE:VST), an independent power producer, rose to about $161.77 by midday. The Department of Energy had conditionally committed up to $4.2 billion in loans for Vistra's nuclear expansion and plant life extensions in Pennsylvania and Ohio. A reliable Friday close for the Dow Jones Utility Average was not available.

A note of caution

Defensive rotations can reverse quickly when risk appetite returns, as Friday's rebound in software showed. Real estate, another rate-sensitive group, led the S&P 500 on Friday, helped by tower stocks after SpaceX (NASDAQ:SPCX) agreed to buy nationwide wireless spectrum. Deutsche Bank (NYSE:DB)'s Jim Reid said "we've now entered what has historically been a much stronger seasonal period," a view that, if it plays out, could pull money back toward growth sectors.

Rate Data and Risk Appetite Decide Whether the Defensive Lead Lasts

The September consumer price index on Wednesday, October 14, will be key for rate-sensitive sectors such as utilities, followed by producer prices on Thursday. PG&E's third-quarter call is on October 22. The bond market is closed on Monday for Columbus Day while stocks trade. The Fed meets October 27–28.