Key Highlights

  • Energy stocks had the roughest day of any S&P 500 group as crude prices fell.
  • WTI crude settled down $3.22 at $89.38 a barrel, and Brent futures closed down $2.69 at $102.59.
  • Exxon Mobil, Chevron and SLB declined, while Sable Offshore said its Platform Hondo restart slipped to the fourth quarter.
  • Despite Tuesday's drop, Brent remains on track for a double-digit gain in September after a strong run.

Oil producers and service companies slid on Tuesday as crude fell hard on recovering Middle East exports and a US offer to release emergency barrels.

The roughest day in the S&P 500

Energy stocks had the roughest day of any group in the S&P 500 on Tuesday. The Energy Select Sector SPDR fund finished as the worst-performing sector ETF, as crude prices tumbled.

The trigger was oil itself. US West Texas Intermediate crude settled down $3.22 at $89.38 a barrel, and Brent crude futures closed down $2.69 at $102.59.

Why crude fell

Supply from the Middle East is coming back. Middle East crude exports in September rebounded to around 16 million barrels per day, the highest level since the war began in late February. Saudi Arabia resumed tanker loadings at Yanbu after restarting its East-West Pipeline.

Dennis Kissler, senior vice president of trading at BOK Financial (NASDAQ:BOKF), said that oil was "under pressure this morning on news that the Saudi's East/West pipeline flows have moved up."

Washington added to the pressure. The Department of Energy offered up to 40 million barrels from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. US and Iranian officials also held separate indirect talks with mediators, and Qatar said mediation continues.

The names that fell

The big integrated oil companies declined. Exxon Mobil (NYSE:XOM) fell as energy stocks broadly declined. Chevron (NYSE:CVX) also slipped alongside lower oil prices. Market commentary noted a preliminary agreement in Vietnam and a Mediterranean gas expansion for Chevron, but said neither has a firm timeline.

Oilfield services giant SLB (NYSE:SLB) dropped too. SLB moved with the energy sector as crude slid.

The logic is simple. Energy company profits rise and fall with commodity prices. When crude drops sharply, investors mark down expected earnings for producers and for the service firms that drill and maintain wells.

Smaller energy names had their own stories. Sable Offshore (NYSE:SOC) said the restart of its Platform Hondo slipped to the fourth quarter from September. Stifel (NYSE:SF) reiterated a Buy rating, saying that "The delays stem from surface level constraints rather than reservoir concerns."

Who gained from cheaper oil

Lower fuel costs helped energy-hungry industries. Cruise stocks rallied behind Carnival (NYSE:CCL)'s strong quarterly results, and Royal Caribbean (NYSE:RCL) also rose, with lower oil cited as a help. Airlines remain sensitive to fuel. Alaska Air Group (NYSE:ALK)'s finance chief Shane Tackett said the timing of a planned earnings boost will be "highly dependent on fuel prices and the broader economy."

The wider market

Energy's slide came on a quiet, range-bound day for stocks overall. The S&P 500 slipped 12.85 points to 7,670.84, the Dow fell 131.59 points to 51,349.92, and the Nasdaq Composite ended essentially flat to slightly lower at 26,797.54.

Rising long-term Treasury yields were the main pressure. The 30-year yield climbed to its highest level since 2002. Utilities were the best-performing sector, while consumer staples, materials and financials also lagged.

Despite Tuesday's drop, Brent remains on track for a double-digit gain in September, which means energy stocks are coming off a strong run for crude.

Gulf Exports, SPR Sales and Iran Talks: What Energy Investors Track

Energy investors will track Gulf export volumes, sales from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve and any progress in US-Iran mediation. Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi said Iran expected "to receive the U.S. response to its latest ceasefire proposals."

On the calendar, Wednesday, September 30 brings month-end, the GDP third estimate and August PCE inflation. The September jobs report follows on Friday, October 2, and the Federal Reserve meets October 27 and 28.