Key Highlights
- Morgan Stanley analyst Daniela Haigian downgraded Group 1 Automotive to Underweight from Equal-Weight and cut her target to $232 from $300.
- She also cut AutoNation to Equal-Weight from Overweight with a target of $175, down from $250, and Morgan Stanley cut earnings estimates across the franchise-dealer group.
- The bank cited negative earnings revisions, higher interest rates and oil prices, and pressure extending into higher-margin ancillary businesses.
- The 10-year yield rose to its highest since 2002, while Tesla rose to $378.79 and Harley-Davidson rallied after a Citi upgrade.
Auto dealer stocks came under pressure on Monday, Oct. 5, after Morgan Stanley (NYSE:MS) turned more cautious on the group. Analyst Daniela Haigian downgraded Group 1 Automotive (NYSE:GPI) to Underweight from Equal-Weight and cut her price target to $232 from $300. She also lowered AutoNation (NYSE:AN) to Equal-Weight from Overweight, with a target of $175, down from $250.
Group 1 fell on the news, and AutoNation dipped. Morgan Stanley also cut its earnings estimates and price targets across the franchise-dealer group, according to market data.
What Morgan Stanley flagged
The bank cited a mix of pressures. For AutoNation, it pointed to "negative earnings revisions, higher interest rates and oil prices, and structural regulatory and technological overhangs."
Haigian said "pressure is extending beyond vehicle-margin normalization into the higher-margin ancillary businesses." Dealers make much of their profit not only from selling cars but from financing, insurance, parts and service. If those higher-margin lines weaken, it can hit earnings harder than a dip in car prices alone.
For Group 1, she said company-specific challenges now "collides with a more challenging industry backdrop."
Group 1 Automotive and AutoNation are two of the largest publicly traded new-car dealer groups in the US, each running franchised stores for multiple brands. That breadth means their results are often read as a gauge of the wider car market.
Rates and fuel in focus
Morgan Stanley's mention of higher interest rates was timely. On Monday, the 10-year Treasury yield rose to its highest level since 2002, keeping auto loan costs elevated. Most new cars in the US are bought with financing, so borrowing costs shape demand.
Oil was a mixed picture. Brent crude fell to settle at $100.32 a barrel and WTI fell to $89.43, but prices remain high after a big run over the past month. The Strait of Hormuz remains effectively closed.
A mixed picture for autos
Not every auto-related stock struggled. Tesla (NASDAQ:TSLA) rose to $378.79, according to market data, which pointed to third-quarter deliveries of 486,000, released before Monday, and speculation about a possible Tesla–SpaceX (NASDAQ:SPCX) combination. Elon Musk said: "Obviously, we can't talk about combining companies."
Harley-Davidson (NYSE:HOG) rallied after Citi (NYSE:C) upgraded it to Buy, while RV dealer Camping World (NYSE:CWH) tumbled after lowering its profit outlook, a reminder that consumers are pulling back on some big-ticket purchases. The consumer discretionary sector was trying to avoid a ninth straight weekly decline, according to market data.
The broader market rose. The Nasdaq Composite climbed 286.45 points to a record 27,477.31, the S&P 500 gained 51.23 points to 7,773.95, just shy of its record, and the Dow added 90.94 points to 51,267.90. Friday's jobs report, showing payrolls up just 29,000 in September, cut bets on an October Fed rate hike.
Dealer earnings will show whether ancillary pressure is real
Auto dealers will look to the third-quarter earnings season for evidence on whether Morgan Stanley's concerns about ancillary businesses are showing up in results. Investors will watch gross profit per vehicle, finance and insurance income and service revenue in the companies' next quarterly reports.
On the macro side, the Fed releases minutes from its September meeting on Wednesday, Oct. 7, at 2 p.m. ET, and holds its next policy meeting on Oct. 27–28. Moves in oil prices and Treasury yields will remain key for car buyers and the dealers who serve them.






Please wait processing your request...