Key Highlights

  • Williams spoke at 2:00 p.m. EDT at the University at Buffalo and said policymakers have time to gather more information.
  • He did not rule out more tightening, saying one further upward adjustment may be appropriate late this year.
  • Before his speech, pricing implied better than two-in-three odds of an October hike, which fell to a coin flip.
  • Chicago Fed President Austan Goolsbee and Governor Michael Barr sounded more hawkish than Williams on the same day.

After a September rate increase, the New York Fed president signaled patience on Tuesday, arguing policymakers have time to watch the data before deciding on another move.

Markets listened to Williams

John Williams chose his words carefully, and markets listened. Speaking at the Student Union Theater at the University at Buffalo at 2:00 p.m. EDT on Tuesday, the president of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York delivered a message that quickly rippled through bond and stock markets.

"With the policy action we took at our September meeting, there is no need for urgency, and we have time to gather more information," Williams said. Shorter versions of the remark ended at "no need for urgency."

The September hike bought time

The key phrase is "the policy action we took at our September meeting." The Fed raised interest rates at that meeting, and Tuesday's remarks were among the clearest signals yet of how officials view the next step. In Williams' view, that increase gives the central bank room to pause and assess how the economy is responding before committing to another move.

Monetary policy works with a lag, as economists have long noted, often taking months to fully affect borrowing, spending and hiring. By stressing that there is time "to gather more information," Williams suggested the Fed can afford to see more data before acting again.

Patience, not a pivot

Williams did not signal that rate increases are over. "If the economy evolves in a manner broadly consistent with my forecast, one further upward adjustment of the federal funds target range may be appropriate late this year," he said. He also said, "Therefore, inflation should actually come down."

His stance was consistent with remarks on September 24, when he said another hike by year-end looked like "a reasonable way of thinking about it."

As the New York Fed president, Williams holds a permanent vote on the Federal Open Market Committee and serves as its vice chair, so his views carry significant weight.

Markets took the hint

The reaction was swift. Headlines captured the shift: Fed rate hike odds fell to a coin flip after Williams said there was no rush. Before his speech, market pricing implied better than two-in-three odds of an October hike. The 10-year Treasury yield retreated from its peak after he spoke.

That mattered on a day when the 30-year yield climbed to its highest level since 2002. Stocks still finished lower, weighed down by soft data including a drop in consumer confidence to 81.9, its lowest since 2014, with the S&P 500 slipping 12.85 points to 7,670.84 and the Dow falling 131.59 points to 51,349.92.

A divided chorus

Not all of Williams' colleagues sounded as patient. Chicago Fed President Austan Goolsbee said, "The fact we have been 5-1/2 years above inflation target is playing with fire." Fed Governor Michael Barr said further policy adjustments are likely needed. Fed officials leaned hawkish on the day, though Williams saw no urgency for another hike.

Data, Not Dates: What Williams' Message Puts in Focus

Williams' "gather more information" message puts the spotlight on data. August PCE inflation and the third GDP estimate arrive at 8:30 a.m. ET on Wednesday, September 30. The September jobs report follows on Friday, October 2, with about 95,000 new jobs expected. The Fed's next meeting is October 27 and 28.