Key Highlights
- The S&P 500 is up 838.19 points for the year and the Nasdaq Composite 3,578.39 points.
- The NYSE recorded 422 new lows against 16 new highs, and the Nasdaq 461 lows against 50 highs.
- The 10-year Treasury Yield hit its highest level since 2007 on Monday, and the 30-year reached its highest since 2004.
- Schwab's Liz Ann Sonders says those headline numbers mask a harsher reality for many individual stocks.
Schwab (NYSE:SCHW)'s chief Investment strategist argues that rotation and churn have inflicted deep damage on many individual stocks even while the major indexes held up, and Monday's session put that idea on display.
The warning
The major US indexes have had a strong 2026. The S&P 500 is up 838.19 points for the year and the Nasdaq Composite 3,578.39 points. But Schwab's Liz Ann Sonders says those headline numbers mask a harsher reality for many individual stocks.
In Schwab's market update on Monday, September 28, Sonders said: "So that's bear-market level declines. It's just happened through a process of churn and rotation."
A Bear Market is typically defined as a deep, sustained drop from a recent peak. Sonders' point is that many stocks have already suffered declines of that magnitude, but because investors keep rotating money from one group to another, the losses have been spread out and have not shown up in the big indexes.
How churn and rotation work
Rotation happens when investors move money from one sector or style to another, for example from megacap tech into defensive stocks, or from software into chips. The index may barely move, because gains in one area offset losses in another. But the stocks being sold can fall sharply.
Monday illustrated that pattern. Money flowed toward defensives: only three of the 11 S&P 500 sectors rose, and they were consumer staples, health care and energy. Meanwhile megacap tech and AI hardware were sold. Meta (NASDAQ:META), Arm Holdings (NASDAQ:ARM), Intel (NASDAQ:INTC), Qualcomm (NASDAQ:QCOM) and AMD (NASDAQ:AMD) fell, while Nvidia (NASDAQ:NVDA) was the exception, rising on a record $150 billion buyback increase.
The evidence in the breadth
The breadth numbers back up Sonders' view. Only 125 of the 503 S&P 500 members rose on Monday. On the NYSE, 2,054 stocks fell and 678 rose.
New 52-week lows also swamped new highs. The NYSE recorded 422 new lows against 16 new highs, and the Nasdaq 461 lows against 50 highs. Market reports said the net readings were the worst since October 2023 on the NYSE and April on the Nasdaq.
BTIG's Jonathan Krinsky made a related point: "The divergence in the positive performance of the S&P 500 and extremely weak breadth is unsustainable. Something's gotta give."
What is driving the damage
Rising bond yields are a major force behind the churn. The 10-year Treasury yield hit its highest level since 2007 on Monday, and the 30-year reached its highest since 2004. Rate-sensitive groups have been hit hard. Homebuilders have been under pressure this year, and the average 30-year Mortgage rate has climbed back above a closely watched threshold for the first time since January 2025, per Schwab.
Software stocks have faced their own pressure. On Monday, Meta's launch of an enterprise AI platform weighed on Salesforce (NYSE:CRM), ServiceNow (NYSE:NOW) and Atlassian (NASDAQ:TEAM), while analysts downgraded several smaller software names. Chip stocks fell after reports that OpenAI paused Training of some frontier models.
Internal health matters as much as the index
If Sonders is right, the market's internal health matters as much as the index level. Watch breadth readings, the balance of new highs and lows, and whether rotation continues to punish one group after another.
Bond yields remain the key swing factor. Schwab's Nathan Peterson said: "If Treasury yields pull back (or at least stop moving higher), this could help provide a lift to stocks." This week's data, including JOLTS on Tuesday, PCE Inflation on Wednesday, ISM Manufacturing on Thursday and the September jobs report on Friday, will shape that path.






Please wait processing your request...