Key Highlights

  • The S&P Cotality Case-Shiller index and the FHFA house price index both showed prices rising in July.
  • The Case-Shiller national index posted a faster annual gain in July than in June, and the 20-City Composite also accelerated.
  • Low supply, because homeowners are reluctant to give up cheap mortgages, keeps prices from falling despite high rates.
  • FHFA Director Bill Pulte said Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac will use one pricing grid treating VantageScore and FICO equally.

Two closely watched gauges showed US home prices still climbing in July, even as long-term borrowing costs pushed toward multi-decade highs.

Prices refused to buckle

American home prices refused to buckle in July. Two major measures released on Tuesday, the S&P Cotality Case-Shiller index and the Federal Housing Finance Agency's house price index, both showed prices rising, extending a long run of gains despite expensive financing.

The Case-Shiller national index posted a faster annual gain in July than in June, and the 20-City Composite also picked up speed and came in ahead of forecasts. The FHFA index rose from the previous month and was higher than a year earlier, the agency said.

Why prices keep climbing

The puzzle is familiar. Borrowing costs are high, yet prices are still moving up. The reasons are rooted in how the housing market works.

The most important is supply. Many homeowners locked in cheap mortgages years ago and are reluctant to sell and take on a much more expensive loan. That keeps the number of existing homes for sale low. When few homes come to market, even reduced demand can be enough to push prices up.

Price indexes also move slowly. Case-Shiller tracks repeat sales of the same homes and reports with a lag, so the July numbers reflect deals agreed in the spring and early summer.

Finally, buyers who can still afford to purchase are often those with substantial savings or equity from a previous home, which makes them less sensitive to rates.

The rate backdrop

Mortgage rates in the US tend to track the 10-year Treasury yield, and that yield is near its highest level in roughly two decades. On Tuesday the 10-year reached its highest level since at least 2007, according to several market reports, while the 30-year Treasury yield climbed to its highest level since 2002.

That surge in long-term yields followed the Federal Reserve's decision to raise rates at its September meeting, as policymakers fight inflation that is still running well above the Fed's target.

Hawkish comments kept the pressure on. Chicago Fed President Austan Goolsbee said that "The fact we have been 5-1/2 years above inflation target is playing with fire."

Buyers are getting nervous

Other data suggest the strain is building. The Conference Board's consumer confidence index fell to 81.9 in September, its lowest level since 2014. Jeffrey Roach, chief economist at LPL Financial (NASDAQ:LPLA), said that "Americans feel jobs are more scarce and are pulling back on plans for homes, cars, and big-ticket purchases, emitting a warning sign for holiday spending."

Job openings also slipped to 7.079 million in August, the lowest since March.

Housing-linked stocks had a mixed day. Offerpad Solutions (NYSE:OPAD) rose as yields eased from their highs and Case-Shiller data showed home prices still rising. The mortgage world also faced a shake-up in credit scoring after FHFA Director Bill Pulte said Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac would move to a single pricing grid that treats VantageScore and FICO equally. Rocket Companies (NYSE:RKT) said it would adopt VantageScore as its preferred model.

On Wall Street, the S&P 500 slipped 12.85 points to 7,670.84 and the Dow fell 131.59 points to 51,349.92, as rising yields weighed on stocks throughout the day. Real estate investment trusts were among the decliners.

GDP, PCE and Payrolls: What Could Move Mortgage Rates Next

Wednesday, September 30 brings the third estimate of GDP and August PCE inflation, both of which can move Treasury yields and, in turn, mortgage rates. Friday, October 2 brings the September jobs report, with economists expecting about 95,000 new jobs.

The Federal Reserve's next meeting is October 27 and 28. Traders put the chance of another hike in October at roughly a coin flip after New York Fed President John Williams said there was "no need for urgency."