Key Highlights

● Evercore ISI called the implications for the carriers somewhat negative.

● The three carriers lost about $39 billion in market value.

● Scotiabank cut price targets on all three carriers.

● Morgan Stanley called the deal incrementally constructive for towers.

As SpaceX (NASDAQ:SPCX)'s spectrum deal rattled US telecom stocks on Friday, one line from Evercore ISI (NYSE:EVR) analyst Kutgun Maral captured the mood: "The carriers' best argument just got weaker". He added, "The implications for AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon are somewhat negative," and "This strategic shift places SpaceX in a stronger negotiating position".

Maral's wording was measured. He called the implications somewhat negative, not dire. But the market response was anything but measured: the three national carriers lost about $39 billion in combined market value, according to market data.

What argument?

For years, satellite-to-phone services have been seen as a complement to traditional mobile networks rather than a substitute. Satellite links can fill gaps in remote areas, but the incumbents own large blocks of licensed spectrum and dense networks of ground equipment that deliver capacity where most people live. That ownership has been a central part of their investment case.

SpaceX's agreement to buy Grain Management's nationwide 800 MHz low-band spectrum, up to 14 MHz paired, for about $8 billion in cash, according to a media report, chips away at that distinction. SpaceX would own terrestrial airwaves of its own. The company said the purchase "will pave the way for Starlink Mobile to become a major mobile carrier in the US." In a note, Maral described the move as a clear sign Starlink Mobile is shifting from a wholesale coverage layer toward something more.

The negotiating angle

Maral's point about negotiating power matters most for T-Mobile US (NASDAQ:TMUS), which currently partners with SpaceX on satellite coverage in dead zones. A partner that owns its own spectrum and has ambitions to sell directly to consumers can drive a harder bargain. T-Mobile shares plunged to about $148.58, down roughly $22.76.

AT&T (NYSE:T) fell $2.41 to $22.17, and Verizon (NYSE:VZ) dropped $3.99 to $41.65. Both traded several times their normal volume. The selling spread to Europe, where Deutsche Telekom, Telefonica and Orange also fell, according to market data.

Other analysts weigh in

Scotiabank analyst Maher Yaghi cut his price targets on all three carriers, including trimming Verizon's to $50 from $51.50 while keeping a Sector Outperform rating. His concerns centred on wireless pricing and customer retention.

Morgan Stanley (NYSE:MS) analysts took a different angle, calling the deal "incrementally constructive" for tower companies. Crown Castle (NYSE:CCI) and American Tower (NYSE:AMT) surged on that read, since a new carrier would likely need ground sites.

What has not changed

The deal still requires Federal Communications Commission approval, and building a national mobile service takes time and heavy investment. The incumbents retain large customer bases, extensive networks and considerable spectrum. Maral's comment speaks to a weaker argument, not a broken business, and analysts' views on how much the threat matters will likely diverge as details emerge.

SpaceX rose $2.00 to $162.57, helped also by a Barclays (NYSE:BCS) Overweight initiation with a $254 target.

Earnings Season Gives Carriers a Stage to Answer the Threat

The FCC review is the next key step. Verizon holds its third-quarter call on October 26, the first chance for a carrier to address the threat on an earnings stage. September consumer prices are due Wednesday, October 14, and bank earnings begin Tuesday, October 13. Stock exchanges stay open on Monday, October 12, though the bond market observes Columbus Day. The Fed meets October 27–28.