Key Highlights

  • Brent crude futures closed down $2.69 at $102.59 a barrel, while WTI settled down $3.22 at $89.38.
  • Brent is still set for a double-digit gain in September after the conflict involving Iran entered its seventh month.
  • Before the late-February strikes on Iran, Brent traded at about $72 on the same contract.
  • Carnival said it absorbed a $150 million hit from energy costs yet still beat expectations and raised its outlook.

Even after a sharp drop on recovering Middle East exports, Brent crude remains on course for a big September rise, a sign of how far the Iran conflict has pushed prices.

A bad day in a very good month

Oil had a bad day on Tuesday, but it has had a very good month. Brent crude futures closed down $2.69 at $102.59 a barrel, and US West Texas Intermediate settled down $3.22 at $89.38.

Yet Brent is still set for a double-digit gain in September. An earlier report showed both Brent and WTI sharply higher for the month.

How September got here

The backdrop is the conflict involving Iran, now in its seventh month. Before the late-February US and Israeli strikes on Iran, Brent traded at about $72 on the same contract. Market commentary said that contract briefly exceeded $100 on Monday.

Through September, fears about supply from the Gulf kept a premium on crude. Shipping disruptions and uncertainty over flows through the region pushed buyers to pay more for secure barrels.

Brent was quoted on different contracts on Tuesday. One contract was quoted near $96, while the settlement was $102.59. Both showed declines on the day, and both sit far above the roughly $72 pre-war level.

Why Tuesday was different

Tuesday's slide reflected signs that supply is returning. Middle East crude exports in September rebounded to around 16 million barrels per day, the highest level since the war began in late February. Saudi Arabia resumed tanker loadings at Yanbu after restarting its East-West Pipeline.

Dennis Kissler, senior vice president of trading at BOK Financial (NASDAQ:BOKF), said that oil was "under pressure this morning on news that the Saudi's East/West pipeline flows have moved up."

The US Department of Energy also offered up to 40 million barrels from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, and US and Iranian officials held indirect talks through mediators.

Tim Waterer, chief analyst at KCM Trade, offered a note of caution: "A clearer picture is emerging of higher oil export volumes leaving the Gulf, but much of that increase still relies on workarounds such as ship-to-ship transfers."

What it means beyond oil

A month of rising crude has consequences. Energy costs feed into inflation, which is already running well above the Federal Reserve's target. The Fed raised rates at its September meeting, and Governor Michael Barr cited high energy prices among his concerns.

Businesses feel it too. Carnival (NYSE:CCL) said it absorbed a $150 million hit from energy costs, yet still beat expectations and raised its outlook, sending cruise stocks higher on Tuesday.

On Wall Street, energy was the worst-performing sector in the S&P 500. The S&P 500 slipped 12.85 points to 7,670.84 and the Dow fell 131.59 points to 51,349.92, as rising long-term Treasury yields weighed on stocks. The Nasdaq Composite ended essentially flat to slightly lower.

For India, which imports most of its oil, a month of elevated Brent prices is a reminder of the country's exposure to Gulf supply.

Month-End for Brent: What Locks In the September Gain

Wednesday, September 30 is the final trading day of the month and the quarter, which will lock in Brent's September performance and close the books on a volatile quarter for energy markets. The same day brings the GDP third estimate and August PCE inflation data.

Beyond that, traders will follow US-Iran mediation, Gulf export volumes and SPR sales. The September jobs report arrives Friday, October 2, and the Federal Reserve meets October 27 and 28.