Key Highlights

• A US judge dismissed a federal criminal case against a Jamaican national accused of voting in the 2020 election, finding the underlying statute unconstitutional.

• The ruling appears to mark the first time a federal court has found the 1996 law violates the Constitution.

• Lawyers for the defendant argued only states can set voter qualifications, not Congress.

• Just 129 people have been charged with violating the law, according to an earlier analysis.

A First-of-Its-Kind Ruling

A US judge dismissed a federal criminal case Thursday accusing a noncitizen of voting in an election, finding that the statute criminalizing noncitizen voting was unconstitutional. The ruling by Miami-based US District Judge David Leibowitz applies only to the case of Chelsea Cox, a Jamaican national living in Florida who was charged in October with illegally voting in the 2020 election.

The decision appears to mark the first time a federal court has found the 1996 law, known as "voting by an alien," to be a violation of the US Constitution, dealing a setback to the Trump administration's broader crackdown on noncitizen voting.

A Crackdown Tied to Election Integrity Claims

The administration's enforcement push has become a cornerstone of President Trump's effort to highlight alleged election fraud ahead of November's midterm elections, as his party works to retain majorities in both chambers of Congress. Trump has argued that stricter enforcement is necessary to protect election integrity, while critics contend the effort exaggerates a rare problem and risks undermining public confidence in election results, echoing earlier false claims that fraud cost Trump the 2020 election.

Trump has characterized noncitizen voting as part of a broader Democratic Party effort to dilute Republican political power. Cox, however, was one of just 129 people charged nationwide with violating the law under scrutiny, according to an earlier analysis of enforcement data.

A Constitutional Argument Over Who Sets Voter Qualifications

Lawyers representing Cox argued that under the US Constitution, only states, not Congress, have the authority to set voter qualifications. Every state in the country requires US citizenship to vote, but Cox's attorneys contended that enforcing that requirement against her was a matter for Florida authorities to pursue, not the Department of Justice through a federal criminal statute.

Judge Leibowitz's ruling does not bind judges presiding over other similar cases nationwide, since the decision applies narrowly to Cox's individual case. The ruling could nonetheless prove persuasive to other federal judges weighing comparable constitutional challenges to the same statute in pending or future prosecutions.

What the Ruling Means Going Forward

The decision represents a meaningful legal setback for the administration's enforcement strategy, even though its direct effect is limited to a single case. Should other federal judges adopt similar reasoning in pending prosecutions brought under the same statute, the ruling could meaningfully constrain the administration's ability to pursue federal criminal charges against noncitizens accused of voting, potentially shifting enforcement responsibility toward individual states instead.

Given the statute's limited historical use, with only 129 people charged nationwide, the practical impact of Thursday's ruling may ultimately depend less on the number of cases it directly affects and more on whether it reshapes the legal framework surrounding future enforcement efforts and the administration's broader messaging around noncitizen voting ahead of the midterms.