Key Highlights
- Justices heard ExxonMobil and Suncor Energy's appeal against a Boulder lawsuit seeking unspecified damages over climate harms.
- Nearly 60 state and local governments have brought dozens of similar suits, according to the companies.
- Justice Samuel Alito recused himself, so eight justices will decide the case, with a ruling due by June.
- The companies, backed by the Trump administration, argue federal authority over air pollution precludes Boulder's claims.
A Court Wrestling With a Contested Question
US Supreme Court justices wrestled with complex questions over whether to let local governments try to hold oil companies liable for the harms caused by climate change, as they opened their new nine-month term on Monday. They heard an appeal filed by ExxonMobil and Suncor Energy after Colorado's top court allowed a lawsuit by officials in Boulder, Colorado, accusing the companies of violating state law and seeking unspecified monetary damages.
The companies, backed by President Donald Trump's administration, argue that the federal government's authority to regulate air pollution precludes Boulder's claims. Questions from the justices reflected concern about unduly limiting states' authority to pursue climate-related litigation, as well as the potential for chaos if local governments across the country were permitted to sue.
What Boulder Alleges
Boulder's city and county governments have accused Exxon and Suncor of helping drive climate change and misleading the public about the risks of fossil fuels. Boulder aims to hold them liable for past and future costs, such as infrastructure repairs, emergency management and harms to public health, tied to the effects of climate change such as wildfires, droughts and floods.
Nearly 60 state and local governments have brought dozens of similar suits seeking billions of dollars in damages from fossil fuel companies, with more continuing to be filed, according to Exxon and Suncor. A ruling for the companies leaves many of those cases open to dismissal.
Questions From the Bench
Chief Justice John Roberts pressed a lawyer for the oil companies and a Justice Department lawyer representing the Trump administration on why state lawsuits are barred when such litigation has been allowed in similar contexts. He said he was not quite sure what makes this situation different.
Justice Sonia Sotomayor pushed back on the contention that Congress foreclosed state lawsuits through the Clean Air Act, noting that the court has permitted such actions under state law in the Clean Water Act. Justice Brett Kavanaugh said the court's prior rulings make clear that interstate air and water pollution are matters for federal law unless Congress specifically preserves state law, and he pressed Boulder's lawyer on a wall of precedent.
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson said some of her colleagues' questions made her think the case is at an early stage and that the court's exercise of jurisdiction is premature. A lawyer for the companies replied that the Colorado Supreme Court and other lower courts have fully decided the federal issues and that, given the billions of dollars sought, an answer is needed sooner rather than later.
Eight Justices Will Decide
The court has a 6-3 conservative majority, but Justice Samuel Alito has recused himself, so eight justices will rule. Alito owns stock in several oil and gas companies but not Exxon or Suncor, according to his financial disclosure forms.
Energy companies and trade groups, along with allied states, have built a largely winning record at the Supreme Court over the past two decades in cases involving climate liability and the reach of federal environmental regulation. A decision is due by the end of June.
Where Things Stand
The ruling, expected by the end of June, may determine whether dozens of similar climate liability suits proceed or face dismissal nationwide. Companies and local governments alike may continue to watch for signals from the eight-justice panel as the case moves forward.






Please wait processing your request...