Key Highlights
- The SEC is not charging BlackRock, Vanguard or State Street over actions with Climate Action 100+ before Exxon's 2021 meeting.
- A rare Report of Investigation says membership in certain groups could cost investors eligibility for cheaper disclosure forms.
- The SEC urged all large investors to review their regulatory obligations before next year's proxy season.
- BlackRock and State Street largely stepped back from the group in early 2024, while Vanguard never joined.
No Charges, but a Warning
The US Securities and Exchange Commission said on Wednesday it is not charging top asset managers over their actions with a climate group ahead of ExxonMobil's 2021 Shareholder meeting. Wall Street's top regulator warned, however, that it remains concerned about investors' work with the group, known as Climate Action 100+, and urged all large investors to review their regulatory obligations ahead of next year's proxy season.
The decision is a partial win for the fund firms mentioned by the agency, including BlackRock, Vanguard and State Street, since they avoid charges that could have carried financial penalties. Known for their big passive funds, the three asset managers typically own top stakes in S&P 500 companies. None of the three immediately commented on the report, and ExxonMobil did not respond immediately to a request for comment.
A Rare Report and the Disclosure Question
The agency released a rare "Report of Investigation" suggesting that certain approaches to raising environmental issues could still trigger more expensive reporting requirements. "Membership in an organization whose stated purpose is to change or influence control of a specific issuer by promoting the election of dissident directors or otherwise could be a Factor in the loss of eligibility" to use the cheaper forms, the report states. In practice, passive holders that qualify use a shorter ownership filing, while investors seeking to influence control file a more detailed one.
The report also detailed how some pension fund members of Climate Action 100+ pressured the asset managers to take tougher stances. Jim Moloney, director of the SEC's Division of Corporation Finance, said the report "reminds asset managers and investors of their responsibilities with respect to shareholder engagement, especially in the context of organized efforts that follow a playbook similar to that of Climate Action 100+. Shareholders have the right to express their views on a particular topic and explain their voting decisions." SEC officials said the approach leaves room for traditional investor communications.
The general counsel of the sustainability nonprofit that coordinates the group's work in North America said it has always operated within US securities law to help investors assess the financial risks of climate change. "It is up to every participating Climate Action 100+ investor to make their own decisions, including how they vote their shares," the general counsel said in a statement.
The SEC is set up as a bipartisan agency but currently operates with only two Republican members, including Chairman Paul Atkins. Last year it tightened reporting guidance for fund managers who pressure companies on ESG issues, and BlackRock and Vanguard softened their interactions to avoid a higher, more expensive level of disclosure of their holdings.
From the 2021 Exxon Contest to Today
Exxon's 2021 shareholder meeting became a flashpoint in a broader debate over how investors and corporate America weigh environmental, social or governance factors such as climate change. BlackRock, Vanguard and State Street backed some dissident directors from a slate put forward by activist hedge fund Engine No. 1, which argued the Texas oil company needed to focus on the energy transition. Climate Action 100+ aligned with Engine No. 1 ahead of the meeting.
Republican politicians, often from energy-producing states, have criticized asset managers over their ESG stances since then, and President Donald Trump issued executive orders on retaking office in 2025 pressuring companies to abandon ESG considerations. BlackRock joined the group in 2020 but largely stepped back in early 2024, citing legal considerations, and State Street also quit at that time. Vanguard never joined and was the first of the three to leave a different fund industry climate group in 2022, citing a need for independence. A 2024 report from a Republican-led congressional committee showed BlackRock and State Street had been wary of joining the group for fear of antitrust concerns or image problems. Trade reporting in late 2024 said more than 70 investors had left the coalition since that committee began its inquiry, and members have denied the antitrust allegations.
Compliance Markers to Follow
The points to track are how large investors adjust their engagement before next year's proxy season, whether more asset managers review membership in organized climate groups, and how the SEC applies the eligibility language from its report to disclosure filings.






Please wait processing your request...