Key Highlights
- New York's attorney general led a coalition of 25 states and cities in suing the EPA to block its repeal of 2024 power plant emission limits.
- The lawsuit challenges the repeal of the Carbon Pollution Standards, which required carbon capture technology at power plants.
- Power plants are the second-largest source of US greenhouse gas emissions after vehicles, accounting for one-quarter of the country's carbon dioxide output.
- The coalition also notified the EPA of its intent to sue separately over the agency's failure to regulate existing natural gas power plants.
A Coalition Challenges the Repeal
New York's attorney general led a coalition of 25 states and cities on Thursday in a lawsuit against the Trump administration's Environmental Protection Agency, seeking to block its repeal of greenhouse gas emission limits for power plants. Attorney General Letitia James and states including California and Michigan filed the lawsuit in the US Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit, challenging the agency's repeal of the 2024 Carbon Pollution Standards, which had required US power plants to reduce their greenhouse gas emissions by installing carbon capture technology.
"Dismantling these protections is a betrayal of American families, and the stakes are too high to allow this administration to once again put profits over people," James said.
Targeting a Major Source of Emissions
Power plants rank as the second-largest source of US greenhouse gas emissions after vehicles, accounting for one-quarter of the nation's carbon dioxide emissions. The scale of that contribution underscores why the coalition has prioritized challenging the repeal, arguing that removing the carbon capture requirement would allow a substantial source of emissions to continue largely unchecked.
The coalition filed a formal petition to strike down the repeal, while separately notifying the EPA that it intends to sue over what it describes as the agency's continued failure to fully regulate pollution from existing natural gas power plants, a gap the states argue leaves a significant portion of the power sector's emissions outside any federal limit.
States Argue the EPA Ignored Key Considerations
The coalition's lawsuit asserts that the EPA revoked the carbon pollution regulations without considering "reasonable alternatives" or adequately factoring in the health and climate costs associated with allowing additional pollution into the atmosphere. The argument centers on procedural grounds as much as substantive policy disagreement, suggesting the states believe the agency's rulemaking process itself was deficient, independent of whether the underlying policy judgment was sound.
This procedural framing often proves significant in environmental litigation, as courts reviewing agency rule changes frequently focus heavily on whether the agency adequately considered alternatives and documented its reasoning, rather than solely on the substantive merits of the policy change itself.
Part of a Broader Pattern of State-Federal Conflict
The lawsuit adds to a growing list of legal challenges state attorneys general have brought against the Trump administration's environmental and energy policy rollbacks. As the administration has moved to ease regulatory requirements across a range of sectors, Democratic-led states have increasingly turned to litigation as their primary tool for contesting those changes, particularly in policy areas where state enforcement authority intersects with federal environmental law.
How the DC Circuit ultimately rules on the coalition's petition, and how quickly the EPA responds to the states' separate notice regarding natural gas power plants, will likely shape the broader trajectory of power sector emissions regulation heading into the next several years.






Please wait processing your request...