Key Highlights

• Just 15% of Americans expressed confidence in big Business in an April survey, close to an all-time low, compared with over 70% who trust small firms.

• New World Bank data covering 164 countries finds that firms in high-income economies grow substantially larger over time than those in poorer countries.

• Across the OECD, small and medium enterprises average just two-thirds the productivity of large firms, and firm-level productivity tracks almost one-for-one with a country's GDP per person.

• Poor countries are distinguished less by an excess of small firms than by a "missing top" of large, productive companies, according to the research.

New Global Data Points to Bigness, Not Smallness

In 2023 The World Bank overhauled its enterprise surveys, which question thousands of companies across hundreds of characteristics, expanding coverage to include major economies previously missing from the data. The latest release in May was the first to incorporate the full expanded dataset. According to Jorge Luis Rodríguez Meza, who runs the surveys, the pattern across all 164 countries surveyed is unambiguous: firms in high-income economies grow considerably larger over their lifespans than those in poorer countries. Across rich economies, firms older than 25 years are on average two-thirds larger by employee count than when they were between one and five years old. In poor economies, the equivalent gap is only one-third.

The finding echoes, at far greater scale, a widely cited 2014 paper examining factories in America, India and Mexico. That research found 40-year-old American plants employed nearly eight times as many workers as five-year-old plants, compared with just over double in Mexico, while in India older factories actually employed fewer workers than newer ones. Rodríguez Meza argues that the gap separating poor countries from rich ones is not an excess of small firms so much as a "missing top" of large companies.

Why Firm Size Tracks National Prosperity

The gap in economic performance between rich and poor places runs directly through the productivity of their firms. Across the OECD, small and medium enterprises average just two-thirds the productivity of large firms, and a country's firm-level labor productivity moves almost one-for-one with its GDP per person. Diego Restuccia of the University of Toronto, drawing on the same World Bank data, notes that poor countries also display far greater productivity disparities even among similarly sized firms, suggesting weaker market discipline against unproductive businesses. Bigness alone is therefore not sufficient for high productivity, since state-owned firms common in poorer countries are often shielded from competitive pressure, whereas in rich economies good businesses tend to grow while bad ones wither.

A Reassessment at the World Bank Itself

The findings have prompted internal reflection at the World Bank, which has long prioritized supporting small and medium enterprises as, in Rodríguez Meza's words, "the good guys." His updated conclusion is more measured: small firms themselves matter little if they are unable to grow into large ones.

Conclusion

The research suggests that American antipathy toward big business, however understandable given legitimate concerns about market power, may obscure the degree to which large, mature firms are themselves a marker of and contributor to national prosperity rather than simply its byproduct. Whether this growing body of evidence meaningfully shifts American public opinion or policy priorities away from reflexive suspicion of scale will likely depend on how effectively the distinction between market power and productive scale is communicated beyond academic and policy circles.