Key Highlights

  • Gold futures rose to about $4,190 an ounce while silver futures slipped to $61.24 on Tuesday.
  • On Monday, September 28, spot silver dropped sharply to $60.81, while spot gold fell to $4,127.
  • Silver is both a store of value and an industrial metal, so it is more sensitive to the economic outlook.
  • Freeport-McMoRan fell and MP Materials declined again as the materials sector lagged in the S&P 500.

Silver extended its losses on Tuesday while gold bounced, highlighting how the two precious metals can part ways when industrial demand and investor sentiment pull in different directions.

Gold and silver part ways

Gold and silver usually move together, but not on Tuesday. Gold futures rose to about $4,190 an ounce, recovering some of Monday's heavy losses. Silver futures, by contrast, slipped to $61.24 an ounce.

Market commentary noted that silver turned negative during the session.

A rough two days for silver

The dip added to Monday's pain. On Monday, September 28, spot silver dropped sharply to $60.81, while spot gold fell to $4,127. Those spot prices are not directly comparable with Tuesday's futures quotes, but the direction was clear: gold bounced back on Tuesday, and silver did not.

Tuesday's decline was modest compared with Monday's, but it showed silver lagging its more famous cousin at a moment when gold buyers were stepping back in after Monday's rout.

Why silver and gold can diverge

Silver has a split personality. Like gold, it is bought as a store of value and a hedge against inflation. But it is also an industrial metal, used in electronics, solar panels and other manufacturing. That means silver is more sensitive to the economic outlook than gold is.

Tuesday's economic data leaned gloomy. The Conference Board's consumer confidence index fell to 81.9, the lowest since 2014, and job openings slipped to 7.079 million, the lowest since March. Signs of a slowing economy can weigh on industrial metals.

Gold, meanwhile, benefits more directly from geopolitical fears and its role as a safe haven. The conflict involving Iran, now in its seventh month, has kept that demand alive. US and Iranian officials held indirect talks with mediators on Tuesday.

Yields and the dollar

Both metals faced the same headwinds. Neither pays interest, so rising bond yields make them less attractive. The 30-year Treasury yield hit its highest level since 2002, and the 10-year reached its highest level in roughly two decades.

The dollar also firmed, with the dollar index rising to about 101.50, a multi-week high. A stronger dollar makes metals more expensive for buyers overseas, including in India, where both gold and silver are popular.

The Federal Reserve is part of the story. It raised rates at its September meeting, and Governor Michael Barr said further policy adjustments are likely needed. New York Fed President John Williams said "there is no need for urgency," and odds of an October hike fell to about a coin flip.

Metals stocks and the market

The materials sector was one of the weaker groups in the S&P 500. Freeport-McMoRan (NYSE:FCX) fell. MP Materials (NYSE:MP), the US rare-earths producer, also declined, again.

The S&P 500 slipped 12.85 points to 7,670.84, the Dow fell 131.59 points to 51,349.92, and the Nasdaq Composite ended essentially flat to slightly lower. Oil fell hard, with WTI down $3.22 at $89.38, and bitcoin edged up to about $83,600.

Utilities were the best-performing sector, while energy was the worst as crude slid on recovering Middle East exports. Consumer staples and financials also lagged.

GDP, PCE and Payrolls: What Silver Traders Watch

Silver traders will watch Wednesday, September 30, when the GDP third estimate and August PCE inflation data are released. Both will shape views on inflation, rates and industrial demand. Wednesday is also month-end and quarter-end.

The September jobs report follows on Friday, October 2, with economists expecting about 95,000 jobs, a key read on the economy that drives silver's industrial side. The Federal Reserve meets October 27 and 28.