Key Highlights

  • The Conference Board index fell to 81.9 in September from 88.6, its lowest level since 2014.
  • Jeffrey Roach of LPL Financial said the reading is a warning sign for holiday spending.
  • Job openings fell to 7.079 million in August, the lowest since March, according to the JOLTS report.
  • Carnival soared on record third-quarter results, while CarMax jumped even as its CEO said affordability is on everyone's mind.

September's slump in the Conference Board index to its lowest since 2014 has economists watching whether gloomier households will trim their shopping lists this holiday season.

An early holiday warning

The holiday shopping season is still weeks away, but an early warning arrived on Tuesday. The Conference Board's consumer confidence index fell to 81.9 in September from 88.6 in August, its lowest level since 2014 and well below the 89.2 economists had expected.

Jeffrey Roach, chief economist at LPL Financial (NASDAQ:LPLA), spelled out what it could mean. "Americans feel jobs are more scarce and are pulling back on plans for homes, cars, and big-ticket purchases, emitting a warning sign for holiday spending," he said.

Why confidence matters for spending

Consumer spending is the largest engine of the US economy, and the holiday period is the most important stretch of the year for many retailers. When households feel less secure about their jobs and finances, they often delay big purchases and trim discretionary spending on items such as gifts, electronics and clothing.

Confidence surveys are not perfect predictors. People sometimes say they feel gloomy but keep spending anyway. Still, a drop of 6.7 points in a single month, to a 12-year low, is hard to ignore.

The labor market worry

The survey's gloom lined up with other data. Job openings fell to 7.079 million in August, the lowest since March, according to the JOLTS report released the same day. Cory Stahle, senior economist at Indeed, described the job market this way: "It's a comfortable place to be if you already have a job. It's a frustrating one if you're trying to find one."

Borrowing costs and prices

Big-ticket purchases are often financed, which makes them sensitive to interest rates. The Federal Reserve raised rates at its September meeting, and on Tuesday the 30-year Treasury yield climbed to its highest level since 2002 while the 10-year reached its highest in roughly two decades. That tends to push up rates on mortgages and car loans.

Energy costs remain elevated as the war involving Iran enters its seventh month, although oil prices fell on Tuesday, with WTI settling down $3.22 at $89.38 a barrel.

Mixed signals from companies

Corporate reports offered a more nuanced picture. Carnival (NYSE:CCL) soared after record third-quarter results and a raised outlook, with CEO Josh Weinstein saying "vacations are sacrosanct" and that consumers prioritize travel "in good times and in bad."

CarMax (NYSE:KMX) jumped after its fiscal second-quarter results beat expectations, but CEO Keith Barr said affordability remains "on everyone's mind."

On Wall Street, consumer discretionary stocks were among the decliners, and consumer staples also lagged. The S&P 500 slipped 12.85 points to 7,670.84.

Weaker confidence adds a new consideration for policymakers weighing another rate hike. New York Fed President John Williams said there is "no need for urgency", and odds of an October hike fell to roughly a coin flip.

Personal Income, Nike and Payrolls: Spending Checks Ahead

Spending data arrive quickly. Wednesday, September 30, brings August personal income and outlays, including PCE inflation, and the third GDP estimate at 8:30 a.m. ET. Nike (NYSE:NKE), a bellwether for consumer demand, reports fiscal first-quarter results on Thursday, October 1, at about 1:15 p.m. PT. The September jobs report follows Friday, October 2, with about 95,000 new jobs expected.