Key Highlights
- The FTC filed a lawsuit against Amazon alongside 22 states, alleging the company deceived advertisers by manipulating auction prices, resulting in an estimated $20 billion in unlawful profits.
- The lawsuit claims about 1.2 million US Advertising customers, including more than 500,000 small and medium-sized businesses, faced substantial overcharges as a result.
- The FTC alleges Amazon began inserting an undisclosed bid of its own, known internally as a “soft reserve,” into a large share of its ad auctions, which the complaint says began in 2019, though some reporting has cited 2018 as when the practice started.
- Amazon shares fell approximately 2.8% to 3.3% following news of the lawsuit, and the case marks the FTC's third significant federal action against the company in recent years.
A Lawsuit Alleging Years of Hidden Overcharges
The US Federal Trade Commission has filed a lawsuit against Amazon alleging that the ecommerce giant deceived advertisers by manipulating the prices they paid to promote products on its platform. The suit, filed in federal court in Seattle alongside a bipartisan group of 22 states, claims Amazon illegally made more than $20 billion from what it called “unwitting advertising customers” through hidden surcharges. The alleged scheme involved substantial overcharges and cost increases for roughly 1.2 million US advertising customers, including more than 500,000 small and medium-sized businesses, ultimately leading to higher prices for consumers, according to the lawsuit.
The FTC's chair said Amazon has millions of advertising customers who were misled into paying significantly higher prices, warning that the unfair and deceptive conduct alleged could have a “staggering” impact given that higher advertising costs were largely passed on to American consumers. Monday's action marks the consumer and competition watchdog's third significant federal lawsuit against Amazon in recent years, reflecting an increasingly aggressive federal enforcement stance toward large technology companies.
How the Alleged “Soft Reserve” Worked
Amazon has traditionally used a “second-price” auction system, under which the company told advertisers they would only pay the minimum bid amount needed to win a placement, according to the FTC's complaint, which cites Amazon's own Marketing materials. The FTC's complaint alleges that Amazon changed its auction rules without notice by adding an undisclosed Surcharge internally referred to as a “soft reserve price,” which the agency says led to higher ad prices. The complaint states this change took effect in 2019, though separate reporting citing FTC officials has described the underlying manipulation as beginning in 2018; the exact starting point differs across accounts of the case.
The FTC alleges Amazon effectively inserted its own bid into a large share of auctions, priced above the actual second-highest bidder, pushing up the minimum price advertisers had to pay to win Placement without disclosing that this had occurred. According to the complaint, this mechanism affected an estimated 70% to 80% of Amazon's sponsored product auctions. The agency's complaint further alleges that Amazon made this change because it was unhappy with how much Revenue its advertising auctions were generating, citing internal communications among Amazon advertising executives, including one exchange in which an executive allegedly acknowledged using what was described as an “invented auction participant” to increase prices. The FTC claims the practice raised pay-per-click prices by as much as 50% during major shopping events, particularly affecting household essentials and other low-margin products where cost increases were likely passed on to shoppers.
Amazon Pushes Back on the Allegations
Shares in the ecommerce group, valued at roughly $2.8 trillion, fell approximately 2.8% to 3.3% following news of the lawsuit. Amazon said its approach to ad auctions had not resulted in higher prices for consumers, stating that average winning bids for sponsored product search ads fell 50% between 2019 and 2025, and that it estimates advertisers saved more than $8 billion between 2021 and 2025 as a result of the company prioritizing ad relevance over ranking ads by bid price alone. The company acknowledged introducing “reserve prices” to ensure ads were priced at market value, but said these were fully disclosed to advertisers and that it updated its help content to more explicitly explain the practice after the FTC raised concerns.
“The FTC's claim fundamentally misunderstands how advertisers operate,” Amazon said in a statement responding to the lawsuit, arguing that advertisers adjust their bids based on real-world campaign performance rather than descriptions of underlying auction mechanics. Amazon made $68.6 billion in advertising revenue last year, giving it the third-largest digital advertising Business behind two other major technology companies.
Part of a Broader Pattern of Enforcement
This marks the latest in a series of legal actions against Amazon. The company reached a $2.5 billion settlement last year over allegations it duped customers into signing up for its Prime membership service, agreeing to pay the largest civil penalty ever issued for a violation of the FTC's rules, and settled a separate case over privacy issues tied to its voice assistant in 2023 for $25 million. A separate lawsuit, set for trial next year, alleges the company illegally uses Monopoly power to overcharge consumers and impede competitors.
The lawsuit also reflects a broader government effort to address what officials view as anti-competitive practices in digital advertising. A federal judge ruled last year in a separate case brought by the Department of Justice that another major technology company maintained an illegal monopoly in digital advertising, a ruling that could eventually force that company to divest parts of its business.






Please wait processing your request...