Key Highlights

  • US coal-fired electricity generation fell 11% in the first half of 2026 compared with the same period last year, according to federal energy data, with declines expected to continue at a slower pace through 2027.
  • The administration has signed two executive orders aimed at supporting the industry and extended the operating lives of seven coal plants that had been scheduled to retire.
  • Coal's share of the US electricity mix has fallen from 52% in 1990 to 17% in 2025, with production down 56% since its 2008 peak and industry employment roughly halved over the same period.
  • Natural gas prices have remained below the roughly USD 3.50 per million British thermal units threshold coal needs to compete, even as the Iran war pushed gas prices higher outside the United States.

A Decline That Policy Has Slowed But Not Reversed

Coal's long decline as a US electricity source is deepening even as the current administration pursues a high-profile campaign to revive the industry, with plant operators scaling back aging units as cheaper alternatives continue to gain market share. Coal-fired electricity generation fell 11% in the first half of 2026 compared with the same period the prior year, according to the US Energy Information Administration, which projects the decline will continue through the rest of the year and into 2027, albeit at a slower pace of roughly 4% and 3% respectively.

The administration has taken concrete steps to support the industry. Two executive orders have been signed with the specific goal of boosting coal, and the president has hosted multiple White House events with industry executives and coal miners. He has extended the operating lives of seven plants that had been scheduled to retire and opened additional public lands for new Mining activity, describing coal in public remarks as "certainly the best" form of energy. A White House spokesperson said the administration's actions have prevented the retirement of more than 17 gigawatts of power generation capacity and helped preserve reliability during periods of heightened electricity demand.

A Decades-Long Slide That Predates Current Policy

These efforts represent an attempt to reverse a decline that has been building for decades. Coal's share of the US electricity mix has collapsed from 52% in 1990 to just 17% in 2025, with much of that loss attributable to competition from natural gas, according to federal energy data, while industry representatives point instead to what they describe as overly burdensome environmental regulation. Coal began losing favor as early as the 1960s amid concerns over air quality, acid rain, and water pollution. Production has fallen 56% since its 2008 peak, and industry employment has roughly halved over the same period.

Market Economics, Not Just Regulation, Are Driving the Decline

Despite the administration's efforts, analysts say the underlying Economics still favor coal's competitors. Renewable power and Natural Gas remain considerably cheaper on a cost basis, with one financial analysis firm estimating that coal now costs more than solar and onshore wind and is roughly comparable in cost to offshore wind. The president has been sharply critical of renewable energy during his second term, at one point describing it as a wasteful trend and halting construction on several major renewable projects, but solar and wind generation have continued growing regardless, up an estimated 21% and 6% respectively.

One coal industry analyst summarized the dynamic plainly, noting that coal is losing ground based on straightforward market competition, since solar and wind are growing quickly enough to keep pace with rising electricity Demand while also taking Market Share away from coal.

Notably, even the specific plants the administration has kept open through executive action have burned significantly less coal than before, with fuel consumption at those facilities falling from an estimated 4.8 million short tons to 1.6 million short tons between the first halves of 2025 and 2026, suggesting the plants are being kept available more as standby capacity than run at anything close to full output.

Natural Gas Prices Remain the Key Constraint

Utilities generally prefer converting coal units to natural gas or simply relying more heavily on existing gas-fired plants. Given the costs of mining and transporting coal, natural gas prices need to reach roughly USD 3.50 per million British thermal units before coal becomes cost-competitive again. For the first half of 2026, despite the Iran war pushing natural gas prices sharply higher outside the United States, domestic gas prices have remained around USD 3.20 per million British thermal units, keeping coal at a persistent cost disadvantage.

A Debate Over Who Bears the Cost

Critics of the administration's approach argue that consumers are bearing real costs from keeping older, less efficient plants running longer than market conditions would otherwise support, with one consumer advocacy group program director describing the policy as effectively a Subsidy for the coal industry rather than sound decision-making grounded in economics. In one notable case, the operator of a coal-fired plant that had been ordered to remain open wrote to the federal energy secretary in February asking to be allowed to close the facility, describing it as an inefficient and increasingly unreliable asset.

Not every analyst views the policy as purely symbolic, however. One coal industry analyst suggested the administration may have genuinely slowed the pace of the industry's decline, since without some plants being kept open by federal order, the sector's contraction could have accelerated even further. A major Utility focused on serving data centers purchased a West Virginia coal plant in July, citing rising electricity demand as the rationale.

Outlook

Whether the current policy support meaningfully changes coal's long-term trajectory likely depends on decisions made well beyond this administration's term. One coal analyst raised the central question directly, asking whether utilities will continue holding onto their coal units if a less coal-friendly administration takes office in 2028, a question that current market economics alone may not answer.