Key Highlights
● Tesla rose 0.95% to $383.72, then fell 2.43% to $374.41.
● SpaceX Merger talks are reported to be advancing, with a deal possible in December.
● Third-quarter Operating Margin fell to 2.6% as Revenue stayed flat near $28 billion.
● Cybercab orders opened at $29,990 plus a $299-a-month Autonomy Subscription.
What stands out about Tesla's (NASDAQ:TSLA) place on Wednesday's most-active list is how ordinary the day was. Shares rose 0.95% to $383.72 on Nov. 18, up from a $380.11 close the session before, on Volume of about 26.9 million shares, roughly 27% below normal by the relative-volume measure. Tesla did not make big news on Wednesday. It ranked among the most-traded U.S. stocks largely because it nearly always does: it is a $1.5 trillion company with a huge retail following, and at the moment it has several big stories unfolding at once. On Thursday, Nov. 19, the stock closed at $374.41, down 2.43%, moving with the broad selloff.
The biggest is a possible combination with SpaceX (NASDAQ:SPCX). Reports on Nov. 12 said that merger talks between the two Elon Musk-led companies were advancing and that a deal could be announced as soon as December, with early 2027 also possible. Tesla shares rose as much as 1.9% on that report. In October, Musk confirmed that both boards had formed special committees to explore a merger. The structure under discussion would have SpaceX, which listed in June and is valued at more than $1.9 trillion, absorbing Tesla, with Tesla investors receiving SpaceX shares. Neither company commented on the report.
The second story is the Cybercab. Invited customers began ordering the two-seat autonomous vehicle in the week before Nov. 18, at a price of $29,990 plus taxes and a required $299-a-month "Autonomy Subscription." Tesla's order page reportedly estimates December deliveries. Cybercabs have been giving Robotaxi rides in Austin since Sept. 3.
A rough Thursday
Like most large technology stocks, Tesla could not hold its ground the next day. On Thursday, Nov. 19, the Dow fell more than 1,100 points and the S&P 500 and Nasdaq each lost more than 2% as investors sold AI-linked shares, partly to fund purchases of Anthropic's (NASDAQ:ANT) record IPO. Tesla fell about 2.4%, to around $374. There was no Tesla-specific news behind the drop; the stock moved with the broad selloff.
What Tesla does
Tesla makes electric vehicles, including the Model 3, Model Y and Cybertruck, and sells energy storage systems such as the Megapack. Increasingly, investors value it less as a carmaker and more as a bet on autonomy and robotics: its Full Self-Driving software, its Robotaxi service, the Cybercab and the Optimus humanoid robot.
Recent results
Third-quarter results showed a car Business still under pressure and an expensive push into new products. Revenue was about $28 billion, flat from a year earlier. Operating Income fell about 56% to $718 million, and operating margin dropped to 2.6% from 5.8%. Net Income fell 43% to $787 million. Adjusted Earnings of $0.48 a share beat the consensus estimate of about $0.45., and operating income did recover from a low of $398 million in the second quarter.
There were brighter spots. Active Full Self-Driving subscriptions reached 1.74 million, up from 1.04 million a year earlier, and more than 75% of North American third-quarter deliveries came with a paid FSD sign-up, Energy gross margin rose to 33.1% from 20.4%, helped partly by Tariff refunds, and the company is almost sold out of Megapacks for 2027. Optimus production has started in Fremont, with shipments to outside customers expected toward the end of next year. Musk said on the Earnings Call that Robotaxi revenue should become a big deal by the third or fourth quarter of next year.
Spending is rising fast. Research and Development costs climbed to $2.76 billion from $1.63 billion, and Capital spending is running at about $20 billion for the year. Tesla ended September with $45.4 billion in cash and short-term investments.
Valuation
By any conventional measure, Tesla is expensive. Its trailing P/E of about 422 compares with about 21.6 for Amazon (NASDAQ:AMZN), 39.3 for Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL), 45.2 for Broadcom (NASDAQ:AVGO) and 16.2 for Nvidia (NASDAQ:NVDA), based on the same session data. On forward numbers the gap narrows but remains wide: Tesla trades at about 176 times consensus 2027 earnings of roughly $2.16 a share. Those estimates have been slipping, down from about $2.25 ninety days ago.
Wall Street is split. The average one-year price target is $412.48, about 8.5% above recent prices, with 5 Strong Buy, 15 Buy, 22 Hold and 2 Sell ratings. Barclays upgraded the stock to Overweight on Oct. 26 and raised its target to $450 from $370, citing the expected SpaceX merger and Data Center demand. The shares are down about 15% this year and have traded between $297.38 and $498.83 over the past 52 weeks.
The bull case
Bulls see Tesla at the start of a shift from selling cars to selling autonomy. Rising FSD subscriptions point to recurring software revenue, the Cybercab is taking orders, the energy business is growing more profitable, and Optimus is in production. A merger with SpaceX could also create a larger, more diversified company and, under the reported change-in-control terms, could revalue Tesla at a deal price.
The bear case
Bears note that the core business barely makes money right now, with an operating margin of 2.6%, while costs and capital spending are climbing and earnings estimates are falling. Tesla does not report Robotaxi results separately, so investors cannot yet see per-ride economics. One analyst estimated the stock could be worth about $360 by 2030 even with fairly generous assumptions. The merger also carries risks. Ring-fencing Tesla's China business is reportedly a main hurdle, and Democrats, who won control of Congress in the midterms, have said Musk's companies and political ties will face scrutiny.
What to watch
The calendar is busy. Tesla's annual Shareholder meeting is on Dec. 3, and the directors who would approve any SpaceX deal are up for re-election. A merger announcement could come as soon as December. First Cybercab deliveries, if they arrive on the December schedule Tesla's order page suggests, will be a key test of the autonomy story. Fourth-quarter delivery figures in early January will show whether the car business is stabilizing.






Please wait processing your request...