Key Highlights

  • One adviser says Nvidia may sit in the penalty box.
  • The view holds until the board names a permanent CEO.
  • Nvidia beat forecasts and raised its outlook.
  • The stock still fell on Wednesday.

The penalty box view

Nvidia (NASDAQ:NVDA)'s latest quarter was big by almost any measure. Yet the stock still fell on Wednesday, and One Investment manager has a simple explanation for how the shares may behave from here.

"The stock may sit in the penalty box until the board names a permanent CEO, and that's fine," the investment manager said.

The phrase borrows from hockey, where a player sent to the penalty box sits out for a stretch before returning to play. Applied to a stock, it describes shares that lag the market for a while because investors are waiting for an issue to be resolved, even when the underlying Business looks healthy. Wagner's added "and that's fine" signals that he sees the pause as a temporary condition rather than a verdict on the company.

A Leadership gap at the top

The issue Wagner points to is leadership. Jensen Huang, Nvidia's co-founder, resigned as CEO earlier this month. Chief financial officer Colette Kress is serving as interim CEO, and board chair Harvey Jones has said the board "does not intend" to return Huang to the role.

It has been reported that Arm Holdings (NASDAQ:ARM) CEO Rene Haas was contacted about the job. Nvidia has not named a permanent chief.

Kress used her first Earnings report in the interim role to project confidence. "Vera Rubin is off to an explosive start, our roadmap is on track and our ambition has never been greater," she said.

Strong numbers, weak stock

The results gave Kress plenty to talk about. Nvidia reported fiscal third-quarter Revenue of $115.8 billion, roughly double the level of a year earlier and ahead of the consensus of about $109.1 billion. Adjusted earnings came in at $2.68 a share, above expectations of about $2.47 to $2.48. Data Center revenue was $107.6 billion, and the company guided fourth-quarter revenue to about $130 billion. It also reiterated a $150 billion share buyback.

Even so, the stock opened higher on Wednesday and then reversed to close lower at $150.96. That marked its fifth straight loss. BofA reiterated its Buy rating with a $280 price target, though the average analyst target fell to $251.74.

Wall Street commentators offered different angles on the slide.

The market backdrop

Nvidia's weakness came on a choppy day. The S&P 500 slipped 16.90 points to 7,323.63, its fifth straight loss, while the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 561.25 points to 50,198.17. The Nasdaq Composite rose 101.50 points to 24,429.88, helped by gains in chipmakers AMD (NASDAQ:AMD) and Broadcom (NASDAQ:AVGO). Nvidia was among the most heavily traded names in the Options market.

Why a Leadership Gap May Weigh on Nvidia's Shares

The obvious catalyst is a board announcement on a permanent CEO, which, by Wagner's reasoning, could be the moment the stock leaves the penalty box. Investors will also watch for Nvidia's quarterly 10-Q filing; the company said, "We plan to file our 10-Q in the coming weeks." Beyond that, signals on AI spending from big cloud customers, the Federal Reserve's December 8 and 9 meeting and Anthropic (NASDAQ:ANT)'s Nasdaq debut on Thursday will all shape the mood around AI stocks.