Key Highlights

● Verizon closed Friday at $41.65, down $3.99, as SpaceX's spectrum purchase rattled the wireless industry.

● Scotiabank lowered its Verizon price target to $50 from $51.50 and kept its Sector Outperform rating.

● Even after the trim, the $50 target stands well above Friday's closing price, implying room for shares to recover.

● Scotiabank analyst Maher Yaghi also cut targets on AT&T and T-Mobile and raised concerns about pricing and customer retention.

Verizon (NYSE:VZ) Communications had a rough session on Friday, closing at $41.65, down $3.99, as SpaceX (NASDAQ:SPCX)'s spectrum purchase rattled the wireless industry. Yet one of the more notable analyst responses was restrained. Scotiabank (NYSE:BNS) lowered its price target to $50 from $51.50 and kept its Sector Outperform rating.

Scotiabank's Maher Yaghi cut targets on AT&T (NYSE:T), T-Mobile (NASDAQ:TMUS) and Verizon alike, and raised concerns about how the carriers would handle pricing and customer retention if a well-funded new rival enters the market. Even after the trim, the $50 target stands well above Friday's closing price, which means the bank's model still implies room for the shares to recover, in its view.

Why the market reacted more sharply

The gap between the analyst's measured cut and the stock's steep drop reflects how quickly investors priced in a new risk. SpaceX agreed to buy Grain Management's nationwide 800 MHz low-band spectrum for about $8 billion in cash, according to a media report. SpaceX said the deal "will pave the way for Starlink Mobile to become a major mobile carrier in the US."

That phrase was enough to send carrier stocks sliding. AT&T closed at $22.17, down $2.41, and T-Mobile ended near $148.58, down about $22.76. The three carriers lost about $39 billion in combined market value, according to market data. Verizon traded between $40.81 and $43.40, on Volume of roughly 88 million to 95 million shares against an average of around 22 million.

Evercore ISI's Kutgun Maral said, "The carriers' best argument just got weaker," and added that "The implications for AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon are somewhat negative." He also noted, "This strategic shift places SpaceX in a stronger negotiating position."

What Sector Outperform signals

A Sector Outperform rating means Scotiabank expects Verizon to do better than other stocks in its coverage group over its Investment horizon. Scotiabank kept that call even on a day of heavy selling. Verizon's appeal for many holders has long rested on steady Cash Flow and a sizeable dividend, and the SpaceX deal still needs approval from the Federal Communications Commission before it can close.

Other parts of the market drew the opposite conclusion from the same news. Tower companies Crown Castle (NYSE:CCI) and American Tower (NYSE:AMT) surged, and Morgan Stanley (NYSE:MS) analysts described the deal as "incrementally constructive" for tower owners, since a new carrier would likely need sites for antennas.

The market around it

The wider market had a good day. The S&P 500 climbed 46.18 points to 7,811.54, about 7 points shy of its record close, and the Dow gained 423.31 points to 51,654.95. Communication services was the weakest S&P 500 sector. European telecom stocks also fell, and the STOXX 600 telecom index hit its lowest level since January 30.

Rates remain a headwind for Dividend stocks. The 10-year Treasury Yield held near a 24-year high, and Fed Governor Christopher Waller said Thursday he anticipates additional hikes to bring Inflation back to the Fed's goal.

Verizon's Call, the FCC Timeline and Scotiabank's $50 Target Frame What Comes Next

Stocks trade on Monday, Columbus Day, but the Bond Market is closed. Before then, September consumer prices land on Wednesday, October 14, bank Earnings run from October 13 to 16, and the Fed meets October 27 to 28. Verizon's third-quarter call is set for October 26, where investors will look for management's response to the SpaceX threat and any update on pricing and churn. Any FCC timeline for the spectrum deal will be closely followed.