Key Highlights

  • Walmart's shares have fallen after each of its last three Earnings reports.
  • In August it beat estimates with $187.94 billion of revenue, yet the stock fell.
  • Analysts expect 64 cents a share, the top of Walmart's guided range.
  • Target's strong comparable sales raised expectations for Walmart.

Walmart (NASDAQ:WMT) has beaten Wall Street's estimates in recent quarters, and its stock has fallen anyway. Walmart shares dropped after each of the company's last three earnings reports. That track record is shaping how investors approach Thursday's third-quarter release.

The pattern

Walmart shares fell after the last three reports because of soft comparable sales and cautious guidance. The August report is the clearest example. Walmart posted Revenue of $187.94 billion against an estimate of $186.71 billion and earnings of 81 cents a share against an expected 74 cents. The stock still fell.

When a company beats estimates and the stock drops, it usually means investors were focused on something else, such as guidance, margins or specific Business lines. For Walmart, the focus was comparable sales and outlook.

Today's setup

Walmart shares slipped 0.69% to $126.48 in pre-market trading on Thursday. The stock closed at $127.36 on Wednesday, down 0.13%.

Analysts expect earnings of 64 cents a share on revenue of about $187.11 billion. Walmart guided to 62 to 64 cents, so the consensus sits at the top of the company's range.

A technical level. It said holding $125.10 keeps the stock's trading channel intact into earnings. Technical levels are watched by some traders but do not reflect the company's fundamentals.

Why expectations are high

Walmart's peers have raised the bar. Target (NYSE:TGT) reported on Wednesday that comparable sales rose 5.6% in its third quarter, and its shares rose about 4%. TJX (NYSE:TJX) rose about 8% after comparable sales grew 4%. Target's strong performance had raised expectations for Walmart.

The stock also trades at a premium. With a Market Value of about $1.01 trillion, Walmart is priced for steady growth. Investors may need more than a modest beat to push the shares higher.

Index context

Walmart is a member of the S&P 500, the Nasdaq-100 and the Dow Jones Industrial Average. Its report is one of the most important consumer data points of the earnings season and often moves retail and consumer staples stocks.

What could break the pattern

A strong holiday outlook would be the clearest way to break the streak. Investors will also look at US comparable sales, which rose 2.6% last quarter, and at higher-margin businesses like Advertising and e-commerce. Clear comments on tariffs, pricing and lower-income shoppers could also help.

Risks

If results are in line and guidance is cautious, the stock could extend the pattern. A premium valuation leaves little room for disappointment. A broader market sell-off, perhaps tied to Anthropic (NASDAQ:ANT)'s IPO or interest rates, could also weigh on the shares regardless of the report.

What to watch next

Watch the initial reaction after the release and whether it holds through the call. Management's holiday commentary will likely matter more than the quarter's earnings per share. The close will show whether Walmart finally broke its post-earnings losing streak or extended it to four. Because Walmart is a Dow component with a high share price, a large move in either direction will also shape how the Dow performs on a day when the Nasdaq is expected to lead.