Key Highlights

  • The Trump administration has asked the Supreme Court to allow enforcement of a new USPS rule tightening mail-in ballot requirements, leaving states uncertain about compliance ahead of the November 3 midterms.
  • The rule requires states to Supply USPS with lists of mail ballot recipients and place unique barcodes on outbound and return ballot envelopes.
  • A federal judge in Boston has blocked the rule nationwide multiple times, most recently after USPS issued its finalized rule on August 22.
  • North Carolina, the first state expected to send out midterm ballots, said it will proceed as planned while monitoring the ongoing court fight.

A Legal Fight With the Clock Running Out

The Trump administration asked the US Supreme Court to allow it to enforce a new US Postal Service rule tightening the use of mail-in ballots, leaving states in limbo over whether they will be required to implement it for the November 3 midterm elections. The uncertainty has taken on new urgency as deadlines approach for states to send out mail ballots, with Republicans defending narrow majorities in both chambers of Congress. North Carolina was expected to send out its ballots on Friday, the first state to do so.

What the Rule Requires

President Trump signed an executive order in March requiring states to supply USPS with lists of mail ballot recipients and to place unique barcodes on all outbound and return ballot envelopes. The order requires USPS to deliver ballots only to voters on each state's approved mail-in ballot list. Trump has long cast doubt on the security of mail-in ballots and has asserted, without evidence, that his 2020 election loss was due to widespread fraud, despite having regularly voted by mail himself.

Democratic Party officials say their supporters would be disproportionately affected by the restrictions, since Democrats are more likely to vote by mail than Republicans. According to the MIT Election Data and Science Lab, 37% of Democrats voted by mail in the 2024 election, compared with 24% of Republicans.

A Back-and-Forth Between the Courts

The executive order drew legal challenges from Democratic Party officials, Democratic-led states and voting rights groups, who argued USPS lacked authority to reject mail ballots and that the order infringed on states' constitutional authority to administer elections. Boston-based US District Judge Indira Talwani blocked implementation of the order in the states that sued on June 25, and on August 11 effectively expanded that order to block USPS from implementing its rule nationwide.

The US Supreme Court last month voided Talwani's June order because the states had sued before USPS released its finalized rule, though the court left the door open for states to sue again once a final rule existed. After USPS issued a finalized rule on August 22, the states renewed their challenge, and Talwani again blocked its implementation. On Thursday, the Trump administration asked the Supreme Court to overturn Talwani's latest order, an unusual move given that the 1st US Circuit Court of Appeals had not yet ruled on the administration's underlying appeal.

States Say They Are Out of Time

Many state election officials have said they would be unable to overhaul their systems to comply with the USPS rule before the midterms. An online portal states would use to upload voter lists is not yet active, and numerous state election offices have already printed their ballots and envelopes. The executive director of North Carolina's State Board of Elections said county election officials would mail out ballots as expected on Friday, adding that the state is watching the courts closely and will comply if anything changes.

The Administration's Position

The Justice Department has argued in court filings that USPS has the authority to implement the rule, while emphasizing that decisions about voter eligibility would remain up to the states. It has dismissed concerns that the rule would cause confusion close to the election, noting USPS would help state officials comply. According to a Whistleblower complaint made public this week, USPS has continued building its online compliance portal despite the ongoing legal uncertainty, though the whistleblower warned that design flaws could result in eligible voters being wrongly denied ballots. A USPS official said in a court filing that the portal may be available for states that wish to use it voluntarily as soon as next week.

A Decision Likely to Come Down to the Wire

With ballots already going out in some states and the legal fight still unresolved, the practical question of whether the rule applies to this year's midterms may not be settled until close to, or even after, ballots have already been mailed in many states.