Key Highlights

  • Several participants said Monetary Policy is not the tool for financial stability risks.
  • Interest rates are a blunt instrument that affects the whole economy.
  • Rate policy still centers on inflation.
  • Officials also flagged worries about Debt tied to the AI boom.

The key passage

Minutes from the Fed's October 27 and 28 meeting included a statement that goes to the heart of a long-running debate in central banking. "Several participants stressed that monetary policy was not the appropriate tool to address financial stability risks directly," the minutes said, according to the official text on the Federal Reserve's website.

The point is subtle but important. Interest rates are a blunt instrument that affects the entire economy. Using them to deflate a specific asset boom or curb excessive borrowing in one sector could inflict damage far beyond the intended target. Instead, central bankers generally prefer tools such as bank Capital requirements, stress tests, lending standards and supervision, often called macroprudential policy, to address threats to financial stability.

Why the issue came up

The minutes show officials have plenty of financial stability concerns to discuss. Fed staff highlighted rapid growth of debt tied to the artificial intelligence buildout, according to the minutes. "Several participants noted risks that the AI Investment surge could be excessive, leading to lower-than-expected returns," the document said.

If that investment fails to pay off, lenders and investors who financed it could face losses. The statement that monetary policy is not the right tool directly suggests those officials see tools other than interest rates, such as supervision and regulation, as the more direct way to address such risks.

Fed Governor Michael Barr spoke on AI and financial stability on Monday, November 16, according to the Fed's website.

Rate policy still centers on inflation

That does not mean the Fed is easing off. The minutes said "almost all participants judged that, under their baseline outlooks for Inflation and the labor market," further increases in the federal funds rate "would likely be appropriate." The focus of those hikes is inflation, not asset prices.

"Many participants viewed the AI buildout as a material source of inflation risk," the minutes said. That puts AI on both sides of the ledger: as a driver of Demand and prices, which rates can address, and as a potential source of financial excess, which several officials said monetary policy should not target directly.

Fed Governor Christopher Waller said on Wednesday, "I'm very, very concerned about inflation. It's kind of headed in the wrong direction, and it's spreading out," and floated a larger-than-usual hike in December.

Markets weigh the AI question

The debate is playing out in markets. Nvidia (NASDAQ:NVDA) reported third-quarter Revenue of $115.8 billion and guided to about $130 billion, but its shares reversed early gains to close lower at $150.96. One chief investment officer said, "Wall Street spent two years asking who would make money FROM artificial intelligence... Now it's finally asking who might lose money BECAUSE of it."

The S&P 500 slipped 16.90 points to 7,323.63, its fifth straight loss and its longest losing streak since June, while the Nasdaq Composite rose 101.50 points to 24,429.88. Anthropic (NASDAQ:ANT) priced its IPO at $83 a share, above its range, at a valuation of about $1.5 trillion, raising tens of billions of dollars.

Separating Inflation Fighting From Financial Stability at the Fed

Barr is among the Fed officials scheduled to speak Thursday, along with Philip Jefferson, Austan Goolsbee and Thomas Barkin, and his remarks could shed more light on how regulators view AI-related lending. Anthropic begins trading on Nasdaq under the ticker ANT on Thursday. The Fed's next policy meeting is December 8 and 9, where the focus will be on inflation and the pace of hikes.