Key Highlights
- A federal judge ordered the White House to immediately restore press access for journalists from three outlets after finding President Trump's ban likely unconstitutional.
- The White House began readmitting the journalists on Thursday after initially resisting the order for several hours.
- Judge Timothy Kelly said the outlets were likely to succeed on their due process claim and found the administration's national security justification unconvincing.
- The restraining order will remain in effect for at least two weeks while the underlying lawsuit proceeds.
Judge Orders Immediate Restoration of Access
The White House began readmitting journalists from three media outlets on Thursday after a federal judge temporarily lifted President Trump's ban on their access to the building. Secret Service officers initially barred some of the affected journalists from entering despite the judge's order, prompting the outlets to file a new court notification of non-compliance. Judge Timothy Kelly directed Trump and other defendants to respond by 12:30 p.m., after which the White House's director of operations confirmed in a declaration that press passes had been restored to the affected outlets.
Kelly, who was appointed to the bench by Trump in 2017, issued the temporary restraining order late Wednesday night, directing the White House to "immediately" restore access. The outlets had been blocked from the building since the prior weekend, a day after Trump first announced the ban.
A Ban the Judge Called Likely Unconstitutional
Trump had initially said he was barring the outlets over what he described as "cumulative stories" containing falsehoods about him and his administration. In their lawsuit, the outlets argued that statement, along with subsequent comments, bolstered their claim that Trump was violating their First Amendment rights by targeting them specifically for their coverage.
In his order, Kelly said the outlets had shown they were likely to prevail on their Fifth Amendment due process claim, finding that the ban appeared to clearly violate two existing federal appeals court rulings requiring advance notice and an opportunity to be heard before a journalist's White House press credentials are revoked. "Nothing in the record that predates this suit suggests that the revocation of Plaintiffs' hard passes was motivated by national security concerns," Kelly wrote, adding that Trump's own public comments at the time focused on the outlets' reporting rather than any security rationale.
Judge Skeptical of National Security Justification
The Justice Department had issued formal explanations for the ban to the outlets on Tuesday, a day after the lawsuit was filed, but Kelly said he remained "skeptical" of the department's claim that the decision was driven by genuine national security concerns. He noted that some of the reporting cited in the administration's letters stretched back months or years, undermining any suggestion of an urgent security threat. "Simply put — the record lacks factual support for Defendants' contention that the revocation of Plaintiffs' hard passes will in fact protect national security," the judge wrote.
Kelly declined the Justice Department's request to delay the restraining order from taking effect immediately, and noted separately that such orders are generally not subject to appeal.
Outlets Call the Ruling a Vindication
A lawyer representing the outlets, Theodore Boutrous Jr., welcomed the decision, calling it "a strong ruling vindicating freedom of the press, due process and the rule of law." "We greatly appreciate the court's swift action," Boutrous said in a statement. The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the ruling.
Outlook
Whether the restored access remains in place beyond the two-week duration of the restraining order will likely depend on the outcome of the underlying lawsuit, which continues to work through the court. Both sides are expected to continue litigating the outlets' broader constitutional claims in the weeks ahead.






Please wait processing your request...