Key Highlights
- Coeur Mining (NYSE:CDE) traded at USD 15.20 on October 21, 2026, up 0.50%, with a P/E of 13.76 and a negative PEG of -1.07, 6.3% below its October 13 level, and no catalyst was found.
- Hecla Mining (NYSE:HL) traded at USD 15.19, up 1.10%, with a P/E of 18.34 and a PEG of -1.86, 55.5% below its 52-week high of USD 34.17, with third quarter results estimated for November 4.
- Alcoa (NYSE:AA) traded at USD 40.69, down 0.23%, with a P/E of 7.23, after reporting adjusted EPS of USD 1.82 on October 15 and agreeing a USD 3.1 billion cash purchase of AliGroup.
- Two of the three have negative PEG readings that carry no signal, and only Alcoa had a dated company event in the past week, so the other two moves are best treated as unexplained.
Coeur Mining (NYSE:CDE): No catalyst, 6.3% below the October 13 level
No company release, regulatory filing or analyst action dated October 21 was found, so today's 0.50% gain is plainly unexplained. Early-session volume was 2.026 million shares against a 3-month average of 36.077 million, so turnover was still building. The shares fell 3.14% to USD 16.23 on October 13 on heavy volume, also without a verified catalyst, and are now about 6.3% lower. The latest company items are the late September exploration update for the Palmarejo and Las Chispas mines and its Mining Forum Americas presentation. After the August report, Scotiabank trimmed its target to USD 26.50 from USD 28.50 and Roth Capital cut to USD 19 from USD 21. For Coeur Mining (NYSE:CDE), the October 28 results are the next test. A P/E of 13.76 means investors pay about USD 13.76 for each USD 1 of trailing earnings. The PEG divides that multiple by expected growth, and a negative reading such as -1.07 means the growth input is negative or unusable, so it should not be read as cheap or expensive. Coeur is a gold and silver producer with mines in the United States, Canada and Mexico, and its earnings swing with metal prices and costs. Published data showed trailing net income of about USD 850 million, up 346%, so the multiple rests on a very strong past year that may not repeat. The 0 to 20 band for P/E and the earnings growth filter both look backward, while a mining company's next year depends on metal prices that no filter can forecast. Metal prices, operating costs and the second quarter miss against consensus are the main risks.
Hecla Mining (NYSE:HL): No catalyst, 55.5% below the high
No company release, filing or analyst action dated October 21 was found, so today's 1.10% gain is unexplained. The latest company items are its Mining Forum Americas presentation in late September and a corporate presentation in early September. Jefferies initiated coverage with a Hold rating in August, and about a month ago published options data showed heavy put volume that was directionally bearish. Hecla's second quarter results came out on August 4. The quote of USD 15.19 is 55.5% below the 52-week high of USD 34.17 and 28.6% above the low of USD 11.81, simple arithmetic, a wide range that shows how far sentiment has swung. At Hecla Mining (NYSE:HL), the estimated November 4 report is the next marker. A P/E of 18.34 means investors pay about USD 18.34 for each USD 1 of trailing earnings, just inside the 0 to 20 band. The PEG divides that multiple by expected growth, and a negative reading of -1.86 means the growth input is negative or unusable, so it says nothing about value. Hecla is a North American precious metals miner whose revenue is mainly silver and gold from mines in Alaska, Idaho and the Yukon. The business also owns exploration projects, such as Polaris in Nevada, whose value is not captured by trailing earnings. Metal prices, mine costs, ore grades and permitting are the main risks, and the stock has already fallen sharply from its high. A bearish options signal does not prove a decline, but it shows that some investors were buying protection. Investors should watch the estimated November 4 report for production, unit costs and any change in guidance.
Alcoa (NYSE:AA): October 15 report and the AliGroup deal
No Alcoa release dated October 21 was found, so the latest catalyst is the third quarter report of October 15, 2026. Revenue was USD 3.704 billion, down 7% from the second quarter, and net income was USD 483 million, helped by gains on Ma'aden shares and energy contracts. Adjusted EBITDA was USD 789 million against USD 901 million in the second quarter and USD 270 million a year earlier. Free cash flow was USD 472 million. Early-session volume was 418,713 shares against a 3-month average of 4.642 million, so turnover was still building. The company reaffirmed its 2026 production and shipment targets, including aluminum production of 2.4 million to 2.6 million metric tons, so management sees no change in output. For Alcoa (NYSE:AA), fourth quarter results and the AliGroup closing steps are next. A P/E of 7.23 means investors pay about USD 7.23 for each USD 1 of trailing earnings, and a PEG of 0.83 implies a growth input near 8.7%, simple arithmetic on two published numbers. Alcoa raised USD 1.5 billion of 6.625% notes due 2034 and USD 1.1 billion of 6.875% notes due 2036 on September 23 to fund the AliGroup purchase from South32. Cash was USD 4.4 billion, including USD 2.6 billion of that financing, and net debt was USD 414 million. Full-year interest expense is now guided to about USD 185 million, and the company expects fourth quarter aluminum costs to rise by about USD 60 million, simple arithmetic on two published items. The acquisition is expected to close in the first half of 2027. Aluminum prices, raw material and alumina costs, tariffs and smelter operations are the main risks, and the deal adds debt and integration work before closing in the first half of 2027.
Where Things Stand
Only Alcoa (NYSE:AA) had a real catalyst, the October 15 report and the AliGroup deal. Coeur Mining (NYSE:CDE) had no company news and trades well below its high. Hecla Mining (NYSE:HL) had none either, and both have negative PEG readings that cannot be used. Metal prices, costs and financing decide all three, and the P/E ratios rest on a strong trailing year. This is not investment advice.






Please wait processing your request...