Key Highlights
- The Trump administration continues struggling to influence China's strategy of using government subsidies to fuel exports, despite years of tariffs and pressure campaigns.
- China's exports to the world have continued surging even as trade between China and the United States specifically has declined 25% amid tariffs.
- The administration has proposed tariffs targeting more than 40 countries over excess industrial capacity, extending well beyond China alone.
- China has turned to Investment promises, including increased soybean purchases and potential US manufacturing, to help ease concerns about its export practices.
A Persistent Challenge Across Administrations
President Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping are meeting this week at a moment when China continues exporting a flood of inexpensive goods globally, despite the Trump administration's efforts to overhaul the international trading system through tariffs. It remains unclear how much pressure Trump will ultimately place on Xi during this state visit to curtail China's longstanding strategy of using government subsidies to boost exports and fuel domestic economic growth.
China's approach of flooding global markets with inexpensive cars, solar panels, minerals and other goods has long frustrated Western economies, including the United States, which have struggled to develop competitive domestic industries in the face of heavily subsidized Chinese competition. The issue has challenged both Democratic and Republican administrations for years and was among the primary factors driving the sweeping tariffs Trump imposed on Beijing. During his first term, Trump's advisers pushed China for commitments to restructure its economy, though negotiations ultimately produced a considerably more modest trade deal centered on purchases of agricultural and other products alongside somewhat more open markets.
Trade Has Shifted, Not Necessarily Rebalanced
China's exports to the United States specifically have slowed significantly due to Trump's tariffs, with trade in goods and services between the two countries falling 25% last year compared with the previous year. However, China's exports to the broader world have continued surging, and many economists believe substantial quantities of Chinese parts and finished products continue flowing into the United States indirectly through other countries.
Trump now faces the underlying question of whether he can meaningfully influence Xi's economic approach, an objective his administration has largely failed to achieve so far despite tariffs and a sustained public pressure campaign. A professor at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies, who previously served as an industrial strategy economist in the Biden administration, said there is fundamentally limited capacity to address the underlying issue, since tariffs treat the symptom of Chinese export competition without addressing the structural imbalances embedded within the Chinese economy itself.
Exports Continue to Surge Despite Global Pushback
Despite considerable international backlash over the Volume of Chinese exports, China's overall trade activity has continued expanding unabated. The country is on pace this year to surpass last year's record Trade Surplus of roughly $1.19 trillion as it continues selling vast quantities of goods to markets around the world.
The Biden administration had expressed particular concern about China saturating global markets with inexpensive green energy products such as solar panels, with former Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen warning that a second "China shock" threatened to further hollow out what remains of America's industrial base. For the Trump administration, concerns have focused more specifically on exports of Chinese steel, minerals and automobiles. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, who has led economic discussions with Chinese officials, has argued that Americans should not allow themselves to be drawn in by inexpensive Chinese products, telling the Economic Club of New York last year that "access to cheap goods is not the essence of the American dream," and reiterating in a separate interview that national prosperity is not fundamentally about purchasing "cheap baubles" from China.
A Broader Tariff Strategy Targeting Many Countries
The Trump administration appears to view additional tariffs as the solution to persistent trade imbalances, though its approach has extended well beyond China alone. White House trade adviser Peter Navarro published a report in August accusing Chinese exporters of routing goods into the United States through more than 40 different countries to circumvent existing tariffs.
The administration has threatened global tariffs targeting China, the European Union, India and other countries running trade surpluses with the United States, citing what it describes as excess industrial capacity and production in foreign factories. These proposed tariffs could apply to more than 40 countries and would add to existing levies the administration has already imposed, including tariffs between 10% and 12.5% that took effect in July. The excess-capacity tariffs target a wide range of practices, from government subsidies and currency manipulation to insufficient labor protections.
The administration argues that other countries have used these practices to build more factory capacity than their own domestic consumers require, exporting the resulting surplus in ways that chill production and investment within the United States while contributing to American trade deficits. Many trade experts believe this underlying critique applies most directly to China, which heavily subsidizes its domestic industries. However, the administration's proposed tariffs appear poised to apply to numerous other countries as well, including Switzerland, Norway, Cambodia and Mexico, several of which have argued they are being unfairly targeted. Norway, in a filing to the US government, argued that its substantial seafood production reflects its long coastline, technical innovation and environmental protections rather than unfair trade practices.
Tariffs on China May Ultimately Prove Modest
The specific tariffs the Trump administration ultimately imposes on China may end up being relatively modest despite the aggressive rhetoric surrounding the broader trade dispute. The administration announced a 12.5% tariff on Chinese exports last month, though people familiar with the discussions say the US may formally announce a higher tariff level while suspending a portion of it to maintain consistency with the level previously agreed to under the existing truce. Bessent said this week that the United States and China would extend their trade truce for two additional months, until January.
Trump has held off imposing additional tariffs on China until after completing his meetings with Xi. Evan Medeiros, a professor at Georgetown University, said the administration appeared to have deliberately avoided taking action ahead of the summit in order to preserve Leverage for potentially increasing tariffs later if China does not ultimately provide what the administration is seeking.
Calls for a Different Approach
Critics argue the Trump administration should be working more closely with allies to collectively pressure China over its trade practices, rather than simultaneously targeting close partners such as Europe and Canada with tariffs. US tariffs on Chinese products have pushed additional Chinese exports into other markets, exacerbating pressures on Europe, which is experiencing what a visiting fellow at the Brookings Institution described as an "alarmingly quick deindustrialization." The European Union had set an October deadline for trade negotiations with China over these issues, though those talks did not appear to be making substantial progress.
China's export-driven strategy has contributed to the country's own Debt burden and strained its banking system, though the Chinese government continues to view these costs as worthwhile given the resulting strength of its industrial base and global influence. Chinese officials also push back against characterizations of the country's Manufacturing capacity as inherently problematic for the rest of the world. China has nonetheless remained attentive to the political consequences of its export strategy, turning to investment promises to help address concerns that its exports are eroding manufacturing jobs elsewhere, including stepped-up purchases of American soybeans and Trump's suggestion that he would consider allowing Chinese automakers to manufacture vehicles within the United States. A senior fellow at the Peterson Institute specializing in global Supply chains said China recognizes that manufacturing jobs represent a significant political concern for its trading partners, and views targeted investment as its preferred method for addressing those concerns.
Outlook
Whether Trump secures any meaningful commitment from Xi to address China's export practices will likely become clearer in the days following this week's summit, though most trade experts remain skeptical given the structural nature of the imbalances involved and the Trump administration's apparent preference for preserving negotiating leverage rather than extracting immediate concessions. The broader question of whether tariffs alone can meaningfully alter China's export-driven growth model, an approach multiple US administrations have attempted without clear success, is likely to remain unresolved regardless of this particular summit's outcome.






Please wait processing your request...