Key Highlights

  • Meta faces a critical legal test in California, where a coalition of state attorneys general is pursuing child safety claims that could result in sweeping design changes to its platforms
  • The trial follows a defeat earlier this month in New Mexico, where a judge ordered Meta to pay nearly $1 billion combined across two phases of litigation
  • States are seeking to force Meta to delete data collected from children and eliminate algorithms and models trained using that data
  • Meta's attorneys have estimated potential damages as high as $1.4 trillion, though lawyers for the states have suggested a lower figure is more likely

California Case Seen as Bigger Test Than New Mexico

If New Mexico created the blueprint for taking on Meta (NASDAQ:META), California could determine the company's fate when it comes to critical changes at Facebook and Instagram. Opening arguments began this week in a trial that California's attorney general is co-leading against Meta, following a long list of allegations that the company fostered addictive behavior in teens and children. The trial involves a coalition of 29 state attorneys general in a unified case brought against Meta in 2023, with arguments presented by lawyers representing California, Colorado, New Jersey and Kentucky.

An executive director at a technology law policy institute said California matters more than any other Jurisdiction in the country, describing it as where Meta is subject to the greatest legal exposure and a jurisdiction watched closely around the world. Earlier this month, Meta lost a case in New Mexico that will require the company to make changes to its services and pay nearly $1 billion combined across two phases of the litigation.

New Mexico Ruling Offers a Preview of Potential Stakes

The New Mexico attorney general, fresh off his court victory, told a Business news outlet that the consequences in California could be astronomical for a company that derives 98% of its Revenue from online advertising. Meta's chief executive is relying on the cash generated by that Advertising business to fund a massive bet on artificial intelligence that could cost as much as $145 billion this year.

A judge in New Mexico ordered Meta to pay $567 million into an abatement fund as part of a second phase of the case involving child exploitation allegations, after a Jury in the case's first phase ruled in March that Meta must pay $375 million for violating the state's unfair practices act. Meta has said it disagrees with the New Mexico ruling and plans to appeal. The New Mexico attorney general said the judgment, while substantial for a state of roughly 2 million people, would represent a much larger and potentially market-shifting figure if the same argument were applied to a state as large as California.

Cases Center on Alleged Harmful App Design

Many of the specifics of the cases vary, but they all center on the alleged harmful design of apps like Facebook and Instagram. In New Mexico, Meta is required to improve age assurance models and tools using AI and to develop, within two years, a dedicated prediction model for detecting users under 13. Other remedies include making it easier to report underage usage and partnering with schools or child safety organizations to create reporting portals for suspected underage accounts.

The New Mexico attorney general said the plaintiffs' focus on app design features and alleged misrepresentations regarding safety provides a blueprint for other states to hold Meta accountable, an approach that allows states to avoid Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which has historically shielded technology companies from legal exposure tied to third-party content. Meta and Google's YouTube separately lost a related case in March, when a jury in Los Angeles found the companies negligent for failing to warn users of dangers associated with using their platforms.

California's Attorney General Vows Accountability

California's attorney general, who was appointed to the role in 2021 by the state's governor, said in a statement that protecting children from harm is one of his most important responsibilities, adding that Meta designed a dangerous product for young users, knew it was dangerous, and then misrepresented that danger to children, families and the broader community. Meta said in a statement that the coalition's claims are unsubstantiated and its financial demands are vastly disproportionate, arguing the states have offered no proof that anyone in their jurisdictions was misled and are attempting to penalize the company for industry-wide challenges such as age verification.

Meta's attorneys have previously said the consolidated trial could lead to damages as high as $1.4 trillion, while lawyers representing the states told the presiding federal judge last week that $200 billion is a more likely figure. States are separately seeking permanent nationwide injunctive relief tied to violations of federal child privacy law, including a requirement that Meta delete all personal data collected from children under 13 along with any algorithms and models trained using that data, while also seeking removal of certain features they describe as addictive, including infinite scroll, autoplay and engagement-optimized algorithms.