Key Highlights

  • Several participants noted risks that the AI Investment surge could be excessive.
  • Excessive spending could lead to lower-than-expected returns.
  • A separate passage flagged AI as an Inflation risk.
  • The concern surfaced as markets digested Nvidia's earnings.

The warning in the minutes

Minutes from the Fed's October 27 and 28 meeting included a pointed caution about the AI boom. "Several participants noted risks that the AI investment surge could be excessive, leading to lower-than-expected returns," the minutes said, according to the official text on the Federal Reserve's website.

That is a different concern from the one that drew the most attention. A separate passage said "Many participants viewed the AI buildout as a material source of inflation risk." Taken together, the minutes describe two worries at once: that the spending is adding to inflation now, and that some of it may not pay off later.

What excessive investment means

Economists use the idea of overinvestment to describe periods when companies pour money into a new technology faster than Demand can justify. If the returns turn out lower than expected, firms may cut back, write down Assets or struggle with Debt they took on to fund the buildout. Fed staff highlighted rapid growth of debt tied to the AI buildout, according to the minutes.

The minutes flagged a risk rather than predicting a bust. "Several," in Fed vocabulary, signals a meaningful group but fewer than "many."

Markets wrestle with the same question

Wednesday's trading reflected similar crosscurrents. Nvidia (NASDAQ:NVDA) reported third-quarter Revenue of $115.8 billion and guided to about $130 billion, but the stock reversed early gains to close lower at $150.96, its fifth straight loss. Investors were weighing how much strength is left in the AI boom.

One chief investment officer said, "Wall Street spent two years asking who would make money FROM artificial intelligence... Now it's finally asking who might lose money BECAUSE of it."

Others were more upbeat. One Wealth manager said, "demand for AI remains broadly strong and as long as hyperscalers continue to spend, the broader AI trade remains on strong footing."

Winners and losers within AI

The divergence showed up across the market. AMD (NASDAQ:AMD) climbed to $530.14 and Broadcom (NASDAQ:AVGO) jumped.

But neocloud operator CoreWeave (NASDAQ:CRWV) fell after rising before the open, and IREN (NASDAQ:IREN) slid as neocloud shares flipped to losses. Software makers Salesforce (NYSE:CRM), Intuit (NASDAQ:INTU) and ServiceNow (NYSE:NOW) fell on fears that AI agents could disrupt their businesses. The Philadelphia Semiconductor index has given back a large part of its year-to-date gain since a peak in June.

The broader market was mixed. The S&P 500 slipped 16.90 points to 7,323.63, its fifth straight loss and longest losing streak since June, while the Nasdaq Composite rose 101.50 points to 24,429.88.

The minutes also showed some officials see limits to using interest rates against such risks. "Several participants stressed that Monetary Policy was not the appropriate tool to address financial stability risks directly," the document said. Still, the overall message was hawkish, with almost all participants judging further rate increases "would likely be appropriate."

Two AI Worries Collide in the Fed's Latest Minutes

Anthropic (NASDAQ:ANT)'s Nasdaq debut on Thursday under the ticker ANT will be a high-profile test of investor appetite for AI. Fed Governor Michael Barr, who spoke on AI and financial stability on November 16, is among Thursday's scheduled Fed speakers. The Fed's next policy meeting is December 8 and 9, and Nvidia has said it plans to file its 10-Q "in the coming weeks."