Key Highlights

  • The Nasdaq Composite closed down 2.25% Thursday and the S&P 500 fell 2% to 7,175 despite Anthropic's debut.
  • One investor said combined Revenue growth at OpenAI and Anthropic slowed from 75% to 48% between two quarters.
  • CoreWeave closed down more than 6%, and Alphabet and Amazon also finished lower on Thursday.
  • Cybersecurity stocks bucked the trend as Palo Alto Networks and CrowdStrike both closed higher on Thursday while peers fell.

A Debut That Missed Its Assignment

Anthropic's record IPO delivered a win for the company and its investors but did not revive sentiment in the AI trade. The Nasdaq Composite closed down 2.25% on Thursday amid a broader pullback, and the S&P 500 declined 2% to 7,175.

Investors had looked to the listing as a "clearing event" for tech after months of choppy trading, the Nvidia Leadership scandal and concerns that AI chip sales to Asia are slowing as Washington tightens enforcement of export controls. Many investors and analysts still express confidence in the AI trade, noting that the stock closed 17% above its IPO price and that the offering raised more than USD 81 billion, which they read as constructive for technology Capital spending.

Export Control Worries Resurface

Some of those worries returned Thursday. A short seller alleged that firmware sold by AMD had turned up in U.S.-blacklisted companies, and AMD closed down more than 7%. The chipmaker said it complies with U.S. law. Separately, documents from the House Foreign Affairs Committee show Commerce Department approvals covering over 879,000 AI chips destined for Chinese firms, raising the prospect of slower sales to Asia under stricter controls.

A Price War Between Frontier Labs

The founder of an Investment management firm who describes himself as a cautious bull compared conditions with 2022, when major indices fell in the second half of the year. He said that year still rewarded investors who held the right combination of longs and shorts.

He pointed to price competition between Anthropic and OpenAI as a threat to the revenue and profit potential of AI and the capital spending behind it. He said combined revenue growth for OpenAI and Anthropic slowed from 75% sequentially in the second quarter to 48% in the third, while combined losses rose from USD 7.9 billion to about USD 8.4 billion over the same period.

Buy-the-Dip Habit Questioned

A senior vice president at Cboe Global Markets described a reset of AI in general. He said investors have profited in tech for years by buying dips, but attitudes have changed and buying indiscriminately no longer works because not everything goes up. Nvidia's ongoing declines have shaken confidence in that approach, he said.

He called Friday a wild card, with outcomes ranging from a final washout of sellers to a bounce that leaves the market directionless while Volatility stays elevated. A further test arrives Monday, when Options on Anthropic start trading and show whether retail investors back the stock.

Questions About Returns

The AI boom has come under pressure over the past month as concerns grow that spending on the technology, which some estimates put above USD 1 trillion this year, is not generating returns quickly enough. The investor quoted above said some resolution is possible if a greater degree of commercial and regulatory clarity emerges over the next few months. Investors acknowledged that this is a high-tension moment and said it is time to be more strategic about the trade.

Where the Selling Landed

Neoclouds, the generally highly indebted AI-dedicated computing providers at the outer edge of the AI trade, fell substantially, with CoreWeave closing down more than 6%. Alphabet and Amazon, viewed as relatively defensive AI bets, also finished lower. Cybersecurity was a bright spot: Palo Alto Networks and CrowdStrike both closed higher as AI tools find security holes across software infrastructure, prompting a scramble to patch vulnerabilities.