Key Highlights
- Albertsons begins a two-week bench trial in Delaware seeking more than USD 8 billion in damages from Kroger.
- Albertsons claims a premium of up to USD 6.88 billion plus a USD 600 million termination fee.
- Kroger says Albertsons misread the merger agreement and blames regulatory opposition for the deal’s failure.
- Since the termination, Kroger’s stock has risen about 4 percent while Albertsons has lost nearly 30 percent.
What Albertsons Wants
Albertsons Companies (NYSE:ACI) begins making its case in court on Monday for more than USD 8 billion in damages against larger rival Kroger (NYSE:KR), for allegedly sinking their agreed USD 24.6 billion merger two years ago.
Idaho-based Albertsons, whose chains include Safeway, Acme and Kings Food Markets, claims that Kroger broke its commitment to obtain regulatory approval for the deal by refusing to sell a sufficient number of stores. As a result, Albertsons says it is owed a premium of up to USD 6.88 billion that the deal delivered to its shareholders, as well as the USD 600 million termination fee and more than USD 1 billion in tax adjustments.
The bench trial is scheduled to run two weeks in Delaware’s Court of Chancery before Vice Chancellor Lori Will. Rulings often take months after a trial ends, and the outcome can be appealed to the Delaware Supreme Court.
The Deal That Failed
The 2022 merger was meant to position the two companies and their 5,000 stores to compete better with newer entrants into grocery markets, among them discount and warehouse retailers, online sellers and Aldi.
Combining the largest and second-largest US grocers was challenged by states and by the administration of Democratic President Joe Biden, which argued the deal removes direct competition and raises prices at checkout. In December 2024, federal and state courts blocked the deal, and Albertsons immediately terminated the merger. Kroger, which is based in Ohio, said that cut off its ability to appeal.
Since the termination, Kroger’s stock has risen about 4 percent and Albertsons has lost nearly 30 percent, with both lagging the S&P 500 index, which rose by more than a quarter.
The trial comes a week after Albertsons unveiled a cost-cutting review of its business, and after Kroger, which owns the Dillons, Ralphs and Fred Meyer chains, planned to cut 3,000 jobs and invest in technology to lower prices.
Albertsons’ Argument
Albertsons says Kroger violated what it describes as an obligation to take “any and all actions” to get antitrust approval, up to selling 650 stores. In court papers, it describes the divestiture packages Kroger offered regulators as an attempt to minimize what Kroger had to sell to protect the profitability of the combined business, rather than to win clearance.
It also says Kroger created a USD 400 million executive bonus pool to encourage senior managers to take a highly aggressive approach to regulators’ demands.
Kroger’s Defense
Kroger says in its court papers that Albertsons is misreading the merger agreement and that it kept its obligations, pinning the deal’s failure on regulatory opposition. It says the Biden administration wanted it to sell more than 650 stores, and that courts blocked the merger because they took a narrow view of the grocery market, excluding other large retailers.
Kroger spent more than USD 1 billion and tens of thousands of hours of employee and adviser time trying to close the deal, which it says is evidence it was not willfully breaching the agreement.
Kroger also says it proves at trial that Albertsons is not entitled to the termination fee, claiming Albertsons undermined Kroger’s ability to negotiate. It blames that in part on allegedly unauthorized communications about the divestment plan by Susan Morris, who is now Albertsons’ chief executive. Albertsons says there is zero evidence Morris shared sensitive information.
Who Might Testify
In addition to Morris, potential witnesses include Rodney McMullen and Vivek Sankaran, who were the chief executives of Kroger and Albertsons respectively at the time of the merger but have since been replaced, court documents show. Dozens of other potential witnesses include deal advisers, expert witnesses and current and former executives and directors.






Please wait processing your request...