Key Highlights
● Senators Elizabeth Warren and Josh Hawley opened an inquiry into insurers including State Farm and Allstate, reports said.
● The inquiry centers on claims closed without payment to policyholders, raising "serious questions" about trust.
● Progressive and Travelers were also named as part of the inquiry in some reports.
Allstate was in the spotlight on Monday after reports said Senators Elizabeth Warren and Josh Hawley opened an inquiry into how several big insurers handle claims that are closed without payment.
Lawmakers ask questions
Allstate (NYSE:ALL) was in focus on Monday, Oct. 5, after Senators Elizabeth Warren and Josh Hawley opened an inquiry into insurers including State Farm and Allstate, according to reports from the Wall Street Journal and Bloomberg. The inquiry centers on insurance claims that were closed without any payment to policyholders.
The senators raised "serious questions about whether consumers can trust their insurance companies to honor their obligations."
Some reports also listed Progressive (NYSE:PGR) and Travelers (NYSE:TRV) as part of the inquiry, while other reports named State Farm and Allstate specifically.
What an inquiry means
A congressional inquiry is a request for information, not a finding of wrongdoing. Allstate has not been found to have done anything wrong, and the reports did not describe any conclusions. Lawmakers typically send letters asking companies to explain their practices and provide data, and companies respond.
The inquiry is notable because it comes from two senators on opposite sides of the political aisle. Warren is a Democrat from Massachusetts and Hawley is a Republican from Missouri. Bipartisan attention can keep an issue in the headlines.
Insurance in a high-rate world
Allstate is one of the largest US home and auto insurers. Insurers collect premiums from customers and invest that money, often in bonds, until claims need to be paid. Higher bond yields can lift the income insurers earn on those investments.
Yields moved higher again on Monday. The 10-year Treasury yield climbed to its highest close since 2002, even after Friday's weak jobs report. Employers added only 29,000 jobs in September, which cut bets on an October Federal Reserve rate hike. Traders now see roughly a one-in-four or smaller chance of a hike this month, down from better than even a week ago.
Inflation concerns kept long-term rates elevated. The ISM services prices-paid index rose to its highest level since July 2022. Rising costs for car parts, repairs and building materials can affect what insurers pay out on claims.
A firm day for markets
The broader market was positive. The S&P 500 rose 51.23 points to 7,773.95, just shy of its summer record. The Nasdaq Composite climbed 286.45 points to a record close of 27,477.31, and the Dow Jones Industrial Average added 90.94 points to 51,267.90.
Financial stocks got support from an upgrade of Wells Fargo (NYSE:WFC) by Morgan Stanley, which named the bank a Top Pick. "The headwinds from the removal of the asset cap are starting to ease. That should help the bank balance growth and profit better," Morgan Stanley said.
Large technology stocks led the gains, with Nvidia (NASDAQ:NVDA) closing at a record high. Oil prices fell, with Brent settling at $100.32 a barrel after G7 nations agreed to release emergency reserves.
What to watch
Investors will watch for any public response from the insurers named in the reports and for any further steps by the senators. The outcome of the inquiry is not known. Allstate's next quarterly report will give management a chance to discuss claims trends. On the macro front, the Federal Reserve releases minutes from its September meeting on Wednesday, Oct. 7, at 2pm ET, and the Fed meets again on Oct. 27-28. Big bank earnings start Oct. 13, kicking off the financial sector's reporting season.






Please wait processing your request...