Key Highlights

  • Progressive slid after October's combined ratio rose from a year earlier.
  • Net income for the month was about $828 million.
  • Net premiums written edged only modestly higher.
  • The November report will show whether October was a blip or a trend.

A softer month for underwriting

Progressive (NYSE:PGR) slid on Wednesday, November 18, after the insurer's October monthly report showed a higher combined ratio than a year earlier. Progressive is one of the few large insurers that publishes results every month, and investors watch those releases closely for signs of how its pricing and claims trends are holding up.

According to the October figures, Net Income came to about $828 million. Net premiums written edged only modestly higher from a year earlier. The combined ratio, the key gauge of Underwriting performance, rose compared with October of last year.

What the combined ratio tells investors

The combined ratio adds up an insurer's claims losses and operating expenses and compares them with the premiums it earns. A reading below the break-even level means the company is making a profit on its underwriting before counting Investment income. A higher number means a larger share of premium dollars is going out the door in claims and costs, so underwriting profit is thinner.

For Progressive, the measure is especially important because the company has long set itself a target of underwriting profitability across its auto and property lines. A rise in the ratio can reflect more frequent or more expensive claims, higher repair or medical costs, weather losses, or the effect of price cuts aimed at winning customers. The monthly report itself does not tell investors which of those factors mattered most in a given month.

Financials lagged a weak tape

Progressive was not alone in falling. The financial sector of the S&P 500 finished lower on Wednesday, and insurers including Travelers (NYSE:TRV) and Chubb (NYSE:CB) also slipped as they moved with the sector. Health insurers were hit far harder after the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services proposed a rule that would expand Medicare Advantage audits.

The broad market was soft too. The S&P 500 slipped 16.90 points to 7,323.63, its fifth straight loss and its longest losing streak since June. The Dow fell 561.25 points to 50,198.17, while the Nasdaq Composite rose 101.50 points to 24,429.88.

Interest rates were a theme across markets. Minutes from the Federal Reserve's October meeting said further increases in the federal funds rate "would likely be appropriate," and Fed Governor Christopher Waller said, "I'm very, very concerned about inflation." For insurers, higher rates can be a mixed story. They boost the income earned on the large bond portfolios insurers hold, but Inflation also raises the cost of repairs, parts and medical care that feed into claims.

About Progressive

Progressive is one of the largest auto insurers in the United States, selling policies directly to consumers and through independent agents. It also writes commercial auto, home and other property coverage. The company is known for its heavy Advertising and for its use of data to price risk, which has helped it gain Market Share over many years.

Will October Prove a Blip for Progressive's Underwriting?

Progressive's next monthly report, covering November, will show whether October's rise in the combined ratio was a blip or the start of a trend. Investors will also watch premium growth for signs that competition in auto insurance is heating up. More broadly, the path of interest rates matters for insurers' investment income. The Fed's next policy meeting is December 8 to 9, and Fed officials Jefferson, Goolsbee, Barkin and Barr are due to speak Thursday, alongside weekly jobless claims and the Philadelphia Fed survey.