Key Highlights
● Anthropic closed its first day at $97.17, above its $83 IPO price.
● An analysis of 16 large IPOs since 2008 found many traded lower a year later.
● Underwriters can buy up to 147 million more shares within 30 days.
● Valuation of about 40 times trailing sales leaves less room for disappointment.
Anthropic's (NASDAQ:ANT) record debut has revived an old Wall Street debate: big listings often start with a bang, but the track record of the months that follow has made some strategists wary of reading too much into day one.
What the record shows
Anthropic finished its first day of trading on Thursday, November 19, at $97.17, comfortably above its $83 IPO price but well below its $111.50 first trade. For many investors, the more important question is what happens next, and history offers reasons for caution.
One analysis examined 16 large US IPOs since 2008. Measured from their first-day close, many of those stocks were trading lower a year later. That does not mean every big listing disappoints, only that a strong first day has been no guarantee of later gains.
Others made similar points before Anthropic began trading. "Just be aware you're going to have a pop and probably some weakness looking at history with major IPOs," one market strategist said on November 17. Another strategist said, "It's not so much what happens this week as what happens in subsequent weeks."
A recent example close to home
Cerebras (NASDAQ:CBRS) Systems the AI chipmaker, nearly doubled on its May debut. It now trades well below its IPO price, and on Thursday it fell sharply again.
Anthropic's own first day added to the cautionary tone. Within 30 minutes of its first trade, the stock had dropped to about $97, the worst start for a big US IPO since 2008, with Coupang the only comparable slide.
Why the weeks after a debut can be tricky
Several features of the post-IPO period can weigh on new stocks. In general, early buyers who received allocations may take profits, while new Supply can arrive as underwriters exercise Options to sell extra shares and, later, as restrictions on insiders selling their stakes expire. Anthropic's underwriters have the option to buy up to 147 million additional shares within 30 days, and a separate private Placement of about $26 billion of non-voting Class N shares to seven partners is scheduled to close on Friday, November 20.
Valuation is another factor. One estimate put Anthropic's Market Value at about $1.3 trillion at the close, or about 40 times trailing sales, though estimates varied widely. A high starting valuation can leave less room for disappointment.
The market backdrop matters too. The S&P 500 fell 147.80 points to 7,175.83 on Thursday, a sixth straight loss, and markets are pricing a December rate increase by the Federal Reserve as very likely.
The other side of the argument
Not everyone is drawing gloomy conclusions. "I wouldn't view Anthropic's IPO as a verdict on AI," one adviser said. One Investment strategist said, "I'd caution investors about trying to read the tea leaves from one event too much." The company's own numbers are large: The company reported run-rate Revenue of $81 billion as of October 31, and its nine-month operating loss narrowed to $1.3 billion from $5.2 billion a year earlier.
What to watch
The first markers come quickly: the private placement's close on Friday, any exercise of the underwriters' option, and whether the shares hold above the $83 offer price. Beyond that, the Federal Reserve's December 8–9 meeting and November Inflation data on December 10 will shape the climate for newly listed growth stocks. If history is a guide, the fuller verdict may take months rather than days.






Please wait processing your request...